F1 07 review: The worst moments

Hungarian Grand Prix, 2007, start | Ferrari MediaIt’s been a season of thrilling highs and gut-wrenching lows.

Yesterday I named the most exciting F1 moments in 2007 – here are the occasions that filled me with despair…

Spy appeal verdict

It may well have been the right verdict. And it may well have brought massive international attention to Formula 1.

But it also ruined the season and stained the reputation of one of the sport?s greatest teams.

The cynical dodge of allowing the drivers but not the team to keep their points ?ǣ when one of McLaren?s racers had clearly been involved in using the ill-gotten Ferrari material ?ǣ rightly drew criticism from many quarters.

McLaren appeal the stewards? verdict at Interlagos

Yes, McLaren would have been derelict not to appeal against the stewards? decision not to disqualify the Williams and BMW cars for using fuel that was below the legal minimum temperature.

And yes, the reasons why the stewards let off the two teams does appear rather circumspect.

But no one wants to see the identity of the champion changed in the courtroom. Not even Lewis Hamilton.

Safety car laps at Fuji

Kimi Raikkonen, Felipe Massa, Ferrari, Fuji Speedway, 2007 | Ferrari MediaThis catastrophic piece of race direction showed up F1 at its worst. Caught between the conflicting demands of live television and the imperatives of safety, the first half-hour of the race was spent behind the safety car.

When the race finally got going it was when the conditions had in fact gotten worse, suggesting they could have started the race in the first place.

This must not be allowed to happen again. If the conditions are fit to race, then race. If not, then don’t.

And perhaps someone should have asked whether, given Fuji’s history for terrible weather – not just at one of its earlier F1 events but numerous other disciplines – it was a sensible choice for the new home of the Japanese Grand Prix.

Anything else that involved the stewards or FIA

Threatening a ten-race engine freeze, taking hours to arrive at a decision on the Hungary qualifying debacle, penalising Anthony Davidson in Monaco when he hadn?t delayed Felipe Massa, the non-verdict on Hamilton?s driving behind the safety car at Fuji, the new investigation into Renault??

It wasn?t their best year.

Robert Kubica?s crash

For one brief, sickening moment, it looked very bad for Robert Kubica. The Pole?s gigantic crash at Montreal was on a scale not seen for many years.

Fortunately the many safety revisions mandated to F1 cars in recent years all behaved as they should, and Kubica escaped without so much as a broken bone from a crash that might have killed him 10 or 20 years ago.

Fernando Alonso’s press briefings

Fernando Alonso, McLaren-Mercedes, Silverstone, 2007 | Daimler ChryslerWhether Alonso?s grief was self-inflicted, McLaren-engineered, or both, the former champion has been a malignant presence in the pits this year.

In the second half of the season his every remark contained yet another attack on his McLaren team, sometimes in a thin disguise, more often plain as day.

But what’s worse is it was a campaign of innuendo.

He insisted his team were favouring Hamilton; the infamous Interlagos ??fair play? steward found nothing; he claimed Hamilton had the benefit of an extra lap in qualifying at Shanghai, but he didn’t; he insisted Ron Dennis lied about their argument at the Hungaroring, but has not offered his own explanation for what really happened.

Until he finally coughs up some hard proof (which may finally happen now that he?s left McLaren) only his dearest fans will accept that McLaren were conducting a nefarious conspiracy against him from day one, and not that he just couldn’t stand it when Hamilton beat him.

The Hamilton hype

Suddenly, ITV don?t cover Formula 1. It?s the Lewis Hamilton show brought to you by Steve Rider, Mark Blundell and Anthony Hamilton.

The press ?ǣ the tabloids in particular ?ǣ are just as bad. If your name?s not Lewis, you won?t get a look in.

Formula 1 coverage may have grown in quantity this year, but it has certainly not improved in quality.

With his failure to win the title has come the inevitable backlash. The same newspapers that plastered lies about his love life across their pages over the summer are now attacking him for moving to Switzerland to get away from them??

The Hamilton hate

Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. Just as the mainstream media have gorged on the new-found popularity of F1 thanks to Hamilton, so have many fans reacted by turning against him.

Hamilton already seems to attract a peculiar level of scrutiny and criticism that previously was reserved for the likes of Michael Schumacher and Ayrton Senna.

His every move on the track and every utterance out of the car are meticulously scanned for evidence of evil intent.

An example: he jokingly referred to backmarkers as ??monkeys? before one race. The Hamilton haters leapt upon the throwaway remark as proof that he considers anyone at the back of the grid to be Epsilon-Minus Semi Morons.

But if Jenson Button, David Coulthard or Anthony Davidson said something like that, would anyone even notice, let alone care?

The Australian, Bahrain, Spanish, French, British, Belgian, Hungarian and Turkish Grands Prix

The year ended with a trio of exciting races in Fuji and Shanghai (thanks to the rain) and Interlagos. Thanks to those, and the tense battle for the championship, many motor sport commentators have begun eulogising over the magnificent, vintage season we?ve had.

Play back your tape of any of these tedious races and tell me if you agree with them.

FOM deleting fan videos from sharing sites

Someone at Formula One Management apparently thinks watching short, grainy film of Grands Prix on Youtube, Dailymotion and the like is a substitute for watching races live. That person must be quite mad.

Doubly so given that they apparently consider amateur filmed videos just as much of a threat and have had those deleted to. And still fail to offer an alternative of their own??

Allowing people to watch and share F1 video clips can only be good for the sport and help widen it to a new, younger audience. And I don’t believe it’s cost FOM a penny – except for the huge amounts they needlessly fritter away in legal fees.

United States Grand Prix dropped

A world championship with no American round?

Get it sorted, Bernie.

Photos: Ferrari | Ferrari | Daimler

Related links

Advert | Go Ad-free

8 comments on F1 07 review: The worst moments

  1. “A world championship with no American round?” – it’s fair trade for the “world series” of baseball…

  2. Completely agree about the video thing – compare it with IndyCar where the official site has race, PR and submitted fan videos available to anyone with the code needed for embedding.

  3. F1 does need an american round – but because the americans – have access to so many different forms of motor racing – it’s just not exciting enough for them to spend the ridiculous amounts of money that bernie has become used too by various political leaders to promote themselves – even though we decry the american types of racing – they are still positively in love with all forms of racing – we on the other hand have goverments who wish too control us in every way possible.

  4. The worst moment for me was hungary qualifying: first Lewis disobeys a team order, then fernando revanges blocking lewis in pits, and finally dennis became angry because his two pilots made the first row!!

    I think if dennis and lewis keep cool down (as people in ferrari do), mclaren would win their first crown since mika…

    And yes, many boring races!

  5. Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine) said on 11th November 2007, 18:42

    If Dennis was angry about anything it would have been either the ear-bashing he got from Hamilton on the radio (and perhaps the suspicion in the back of his mind that Alonso would get a penalty for what he did). No team manager would be angry about getting both his cars on the front row of the grid.

  6. My Low point was the very sick Mark Webber, ON FOR THE WIN and getting knocked out in Fuji. Whoever’s fault it was (probably a little of all three drivers) it was the worst moment of the season for me.

  7. During those first laps at Fuji, I was just screaming “RED FLAG IT OR LET THEM RACE!!!!!!!!!!” at the TV (at 11:00… sorry, neighbors…). Thing was, once the damn safety car pullet in, it was one of the best races of the year.

    And on the FOM removing videos – apparently, my five-second clip of Lewis Hamilton coming down the back straight at Indianapolis was a threat to the sport… absolutely ridiculous.

    Still, in spite of all this, 2007 was a great year to watch F1.

  8. Daniel said on 12th November 2007, 0:22

    Certainly my low point was seeing Lewis stuck on the pit entrance gravel at Shanghai! That was plenty of ‘first times’ for me: I’ve never seen a tyre worn ’til the white canvas, neither a driver retiring on the gravel INSIDE the pits area!
    Once Felipe got out of contention, I started supporting Lewis, and from that moment I noticed things wouldn’t be going quite as I expected…

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.