2009 F1 cars: Hot or not? (Poll & Video)

Ferrari were the first launch to launch their 2009 F1 car

Ferrari were the first launch to launch their 2009 F1 car

There’s been a huge amount of fuss over the looks of the 2009 F1 cars. Do you welcome the return to smooth sidepods? Do the wings still look out of proportion to you? Cast your vote below…

The 2009 F1 cars are...

  • Hideous abominations (6%)
  • Pretty ugly (22%)
  • Alright (25%)
  • Not bad looking (34%)
  • Beautiful (14%)

Total Voters: 1,246

Loading ... Loading ...

When I first saw the early drawings of 2009-style F1 cars and particularly the interim car BMW ran in pre-2009 testing, I was very worried.

I thought the wide, low front wing and narrow, tall rear wing were totally out of propotion with each other. And that impression hasn’t changed after seeing six of the 2009 cars hit the track.

I do like the clean shape of the side of the cars, though – particularly cars like the McLaren which haven’t got side pod wings like the Toyota. Charlie Whiting carefully dodged the question of whether the rules were supposed to outlaw these flow conditioners:

We write the rules to enable the teams to design cars as close as possible to the technical spec. They’ve been working in areas they hadn’t previously been trying to work in, so there’s not much we can do about that. I’m confident we’ve achieved a fairly significant reduction in downforce, but that’s not the critical thing: the critical thing is the effects. As long as we have the effects, we should be okay.

I think it’s pretty clear the intention was to get rid of them, but some teams have exploited a gap in the regulations in order to construct them. These teams aren’t doing anything wrong of course, but it goes to show that a fast car isn’t necessarily an aesthetically appealing one.

And according to Mark Webber, we haven’t seen the best looking car of 2009 yet

All these changes have been made in the name of allowing the cars to race each other more closely and if that proves to be the case then I’ll like the cars a lot more. I do think they’re easier to enjoy in motion – particularly when you see how much of a handful they are for the drivers. Here’s some video from testing last week:

More pictures and video of the 2009 F1 cars

Promoted content from around the web | Become an F1 Fanatic Supporter to hide this ad and others

Advert | Go Ad-free

45 comments on 2009 F1 cars: Hot or not? (Poll & Video)

  1. chaostheory said on 28th January 2009, 12:28

    Voted “not bad looking”, but there should be sixth option: beauty, but not all ;)
    Ferrari and McLaren are like piece of art compared to Renault and BMW.

  2. I’m not seeing that video properly. It’s 4:3 footage stuffed into a 16:9 box, so all cars looked flattened, which kind of makes the video miss its purpose.

  3. Keith wat version of Flash Player do u use?I am not able to see any of the videos.Does it differ from the version of BMW testing video?I am only able to see that.

  4. Arthur954 said on 28th January 2009, 14:17

    The cars look OK to me. What they seem is very LONG and big, now even more so with the large front wings. Could it be that the new rules were created so that these cars do not fit on historic venues and existing tracks , and the only way to race them is to go to the new tracks in the Middle and Far East where Bernie makes money for his company ?

    This I think is a serious issue to think about. Maybe some type of ground effect could be allowed in future regulations so that the cars do not need those protruding front and back wings.

    • Pete Walker said on 28th January 2009, 14:29

      Could it be that the new rules were created so that these cars do not fit on historic venues and existing tracks , and the only way to race them is to go to the new tracks in the Middle and Far East where Bernie makes money for his company ?

      In a word, no. ;) I know Bernie is just chasing the money when it comes to new circuits, but they’d never design the cars specifically to suit newer circuits. The cars must perform well and safely on all sorts of circuits. Besides, the new designs were proposed by the Overtaking Working Group, not Bernie. Fun conspiracy theory though!

      Its strange that the cars now appear larger because I think in some cases (BMW?) the car is actually shorter than before. I think its more an effect of the massive front wings.

      I’ll go for ‘Not bad looking’ as the tidier bodywork is a big improvement and I’m getting more used to the new wings all the time.

  5. Pretty Ugly: I think the side views are more flattering than the end views (especially nose on), and I understand that cars generally do not show up well in pictures, so they will all look much better in the flesh, but to me its as if all the designers have gone on holiday (or been sacked to save money?).

  6. It always amuses me when people say things like “the new regulations make F1 cars look ugly” or “They don’t look like proper F1 cars to me”. To my mind they spoilt F1 cars when they put the engines in the back… :-)

    BTW I prefer this years cars – much smoother than the old ones – and if it promotes closer racing then so much the better.

  7. Too Good said on 28th January 2009, 14:50

    Bigger issues on hand for all F1 team, dwindling finances, sponsors cutting back on budgets and no new sponsors coming ahead. Limited Testing means inability to certify on car performance etcetra etcetra ….
    Beauty of the car is last thing on their mind.

  8. Adrian said on 28th January 2009, 15:27

    Not Bad Looking: And growing on me all the time…

  9. Chris said on 28th January 2009, 16:13

    Nice video :)
    Why is it the teams cover up their cars with a tarpaulin and try to prevent the cameras from getting shots of their cars when they break down?
    Is it because rival teams could see the more secret inner workings and design aspects and ‘copy’ them during the crucial testing period?

    • francois said on 28th January 2009, 23:04

      I was wondering just why McLaren in particular seemed so keen to make sure the entire car was wrapped up and went to so much trouble to crane the car onto the pickup truck with the tarpaulin…

  10. Kevin said on 28th January 2009, 16:25

    I like the elimination of all the little winglets and clean lines. I think someone must have fell asleep while designing the nose of the Renault. The rear wings look better on the 08 cars. Id love to see the 09 cars with 08 spec rear wings on them, reckon they would look the bis.

  11. For what they are, they’re not bad looking – as I have said before, they have elegance…but not the kind that F1 cars traditionally had. They just look so soft and tame that I don’t feel like I’m looking at an F1 car.

    So for what they are, they’re alright – would’ve been a lot better had it not been the disproportionate wing sizes. But compared to almost every previous season, they’re just incomparable.

    The title pic of the Ferrari does look nice, though. Perhaps the best angle you could get on it.

  12. DriverX said on 28th January 2009, 17:24

    I dont like the new Formula 1

    I like the 2008 cars with al the spoilers and so. They let me think at spaceships, and that what the have to – formula 1 cars.

    But we’ll have to live with it..

  13. This years cars just look plain, clean, generic, and unoriginal. They’re far to similar to the boring A1GP cars. There’s no edginess and originality where you feel the designers and engineers have thought way outside the box to overcome the technical, regulatory, aerodynamic and other countless other obstacles to achieve maximum performance. It’s a shame but time will tell if the racing will improve, fingers crossed…

    • Thanks for some of the supportive comments. Like I say, the 2009 cars just lack the je-ne-sais-quoi and joie de vivre that the 2008 cars possessed…

  14. Personally the wings stop the 2009 cars from looking great.
    From some angles the front and rear wings look in proportion to the car, but from other angles they look like they have been taken from a completely different class of car on plonked on an F1 car.

    If we had 2009 cars with 2008 wings, minus the front wing bridge such as the McLaren used, then they would be some of the best looking F1 cars for a while.

    The side pod wings/flow conditioners on the Ferrari stop it from being as good looking as the McLaren, aesthetically speaking those aero pieces were some of the worst on the old cars to my eyes.

  15. beneboy said on 28th January 2009, 18:19

    Not bad looking for me.

    I like the clean look but the rear wing looks silly from any angle other than side on, it’s too narrow and should stretch the full width of the car.

    I think Chaz has a point with the generic look of the cars, this has been a complaint of mine for many years and I think the tightening of the regulations is to blame, the introduction of standard parts is taking it further than I’d really like and makes me think it’s just Spanky’s way of getting a Spec series in through the back door.
    Not that long ago most cars were very easy to tell apart, these days it’d be easy to mix them up without their paint jobs.

    Spot

    To my mind they spoilt F1 cars when they put the engines in the backā€¦

    I know what you mean, although I’m far too young to have seen front engined cars racing I love the look of the old cars.

    For me anything up to the first few years of winged cars (is this the right description ? Doesn’t sound right, maybe cars with wings instead) are almost all far better looking than anything made since.

  16. BaKano said on 28th January 2009, 18:36

    I had to vote “Alright”. The cars are quite beatifull minus the front and rear wings. But with such a large front wing, and such a tall and small rear wing the cars become very disproportional, so I cannot say they are not bad looking, because they DO are bad looking! The complete package that is.

    One thing I’m not quite liking is the raised nose, which seems will be the rule here. I did however fancy the solution by Toyota, with the round pilars moving forward.

    The Renault R29 nose is just hideous, hope they can suit a better one before the Season starts…

  17. Tom Bisset said on 28th January 2009, 19:15

    I think most people are looking at it from the wrong viewpoint. We are moving into a new era of formula 1. This is only the start of this new era. People are comparing these new cars to cars of the last era.

    Not that I am trying to criticise anybody (because everyone is entitled to opinion) but I think we should look at these cars with an open mind. Yes, I do think they look bizzare but still, its a nice change from some of the previous models.

    We should maybe take this season as an experimental one, then develop the cars into something more attractive and referring to Chaz, maybe if the teams were to design their cars so that they all look different from each other, so that you could tell the difference without the colours on.

  18. staggington said on 28th January 2009, 20:01

    if it wasn’t for the huge front wing and anorexic rear wing i think the cars would look ok…but then again they will look like indy cars (but not as bad). Also as tom said above, these are the first of their kind. if bernie doesnt decide to change the regulations all over again next year or in 2011 etc the cars will be more developed with little add ons here n there and will once again be works of art!

  19. voted beautiful, but i have to say its only for a few cars. like mclaren which is the most striking and others as follows williams, ferrari, redbull etc bmw is out, toyota is out last but not the least i have to say i have some misgivings on the large front wings which look good but could be a potential safety hazard… we’ll see

  20. arthur954 said on 28th January 2009, 21:39

    Of all the 2009 cars, I think the McLaren is the most elegant, although I love cars with silver wheels, not black. Black I find is old news. Sorry to be off-topic, but to me the pinnacle of beauty where those Lotus cars with chrome detailing all over – was it the late 60s or so ?
    I would love some silver or chrome detailing on modern cars, like in the front suspension bars – that would look great – a more “handbuilt” look. Just dreaming …

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.

Skip to toolbar