Moveable wings making any difference?

We’ve had no shortage of stuff to talk about since the F1 season got started again last week: KERS, tyres, the look of the cars, the emergence of Brawn GP, the BBC, McLaren’s lack of pace, twilight races and the usual controversies.

But we’ve hardly heard anything at all about the new adjustable wings.

Before the season began there was a lot of scepticism about whether they would make much difference and, for all we know, they may not be. Few if anyof the drivers seem to have mentioned them. I haven’t seen any footage of the wings moving and there doesn’t appear to be any television graphic to show the fans when they are being used.

Are the moveable wings making a difference? Have you seen any evidence of them being used? Leave a comment below.

Advert | Go Ad-free

28 comments on Moveable wings making any difference?

  1. Chris said on 4th April 2009, 16:26

    I think barcaello changed them last week to compinsate for when he knocked the end plate off the wing (I remember a bit of team radio!)

  2. I don’t remember who, but in Melbourne some driver said that they were not touching the movable wing because it made no difference and was one thing more to think on. (seems strange, but anyway my memory is not good…)

  3. Dan M said on 4th April 2009, 16:53

    Think that was Alonso.

  4. gabal said on 4th April 2009, 17:07

    Yeah, that was Alonso but it was in practice. I thought it will be used more so the setup can be more tuned towards one part of the track (straight for example) and drivers can compensate for that by adjusting wing levels.

    Maybe it allows drivers to follow others more easily…

  5. Richard said on 4th April 2009, 18:08

    I think either the drivers are missing a trick here or the change is not big enough to have that much impact. Because in theory with the flaps up you could brake later due to more downforce but it all depends on how much extra downforce it generate, im guessing because of the drivers reactions its quite small, and with brake bias kers and all the other stuff the driver has going on its on thing that is not worth crucial time thinking about.

  6. Robert McKay said on 4th April 2009, 18:51

    I wonder if they’re a bit like KERS and used differently in the race from in practice (if at all) and quali.

    In the race the drivers are largely using KERS as an offensive/defensive passing boost, but in practice Hamilton at least was using it in two or three short bursts out of specific corners to minimise laptime.

    Maybe the front wing is similar in that just turning practice laps you don’t touch it, for consistency in determining the setup/balance. Maybe in the race running in reasonably clear air you do the same and don’t bother with it, and only think about using it if you are stuck behind another car and haven’t been able to get close to it in the corners.

    Or maybe the teams aren’t bothering with it – noone seems to be talking much about it. I heard Massa being told to adjust it in one of the sessions but that’s one of the few references to it I’ve heard.

    We should be getting some sort of indicator/graphic to see its usage. After all, all the drivers have it at the moment, unlike KERS…

  7. why nobody ask the drivers about it ?

  8. Robert McKay said on 4th April 2009, 22:28

    This was bugging me, and I’ve went and tried to do some digging and asking around on other forums, and some people are saying that not all the teams even have adjustable front wing flaps, let alone use them. Some people are of the opinion Force India don’t have them, and I’ve seen some people say that Red Bull/STR don’t.

    However I can find nothing official anywhere that says this is true and nothing that says that teams aren’t using it. Indeed I’ve found a Webber quote that he tried the flap and found it ineffective.

    Not sure what’s true, and am a bit befuddled by the whole thing, to be honest.

  9. Philip said on 5th April 2009, 0:03

    I recall Brundle very briefly mentioning that Red Bull don’t have it on their front wing, but he didn’t explore that at all. Commentary immediately moved onto something else. Would like to hear more about the front wings.

  10. Oliver said on 5th April 2009, 0:21

    The drivers can only changed them twice in a lap, so its of very limited use in gaining lap times.

  11. Ethnic_Tension said on 5th April 2009, 1:19

    I think the problem lies with the fact the cars have too much front downforce already when compared to the rear. The last thing you want is even more on the front.

  12. Hollus said on 5th April 2009, 1:35

    I haven’t heard of any use of the movable front flaps either, only drivers saying “nah, no difference”. But I find it difficult to believe that it does not have any effect at all. No matter how small the effect, lowering the flap angle in a long straight should reduce drag only if by a little bit? And in a long straight there is not much to do for the drivers…
    Maybe nowadays the aerodynamics of the car are so fine tuned that even that is more of a disruption than a help?

  13. phil c said on 5th April 2009, 2:10

    I dont think anybody would be stuffing around with the wings. It would upset the balance to much and the drivers would lose feel and confidence from corner to corner. Also i think stuffing around with aero while driving would also affect the tyres to much. This is just a throw away regulation because it to restrictive in its application. If it could be controlled by an air flow pressure meter and ecu automaticaly all the teams would have it. The wings would change angle as downforce levels change, and air over them changes. This would help the drivers because they would have the same feel all the time regardless if there is a car in front or not.

  14. zplol said on 5th April 2009, 2:30

    I think it will only come into play in qualifying on tracks with very long straights

  15. Ben Ell said on 5th April 2009, 5:36

    I don’t think there would be much difference at tracks like Melbourne where the track is very similar style for the whole lap.

    In Malaysia we might see more use of it as the drivers can increase the wing going into turn 1 and then drop it as they come onto the straight at the end of the lap. The length of the last and pit straights might make it worthwhile, while the bit in between is fairly twisty so warrants adding a bit of extra wing.

    You’d need to wait until later in the season when they’ve raced at a number of circuits of differing styles to see what kind of effect its having.

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.