2011 F1 season preview
Drag Reduction System, adjustable rear wing – whatever you call it, it’s a controversial new addition in 2011.
But we shouldn’t be too quick to write off a change that could add a lot to F1.
The wings will look fantastic in qualifying. And if the FIA make the right sort of changes to make them less of a gimmick, I think even their more vehement critics could be won over.
Update: For details on where drivers can use DRS on different circuits, see the circuit information pages:
Why DRS will be great in qualifying
The adjustable rear wings should make qualifying an even more spectacular sight.
As in practice, drivers will have free use of the wings during qualifying. That means we’re going to see drivers dropping the wings at every opportunity between corners.
We’re going to be able to see the difference in performance between cars and drivers like never before. The cars with the best traction will be able to deploy their wings early on the way out of corners.
If FOM are on the ball, side-by-side comparisons of different cars and drivers using their wings on bends will make for fascinating viewing.
Steps have been taken to ensure the systems are safe. Crucially, in the event of a failure the flow of air should force the wing back into position where the slot is closed, giving the driver maximum downforce.
See the DRS in action in this video from Red Bull:
DRS in the races: a gimmick
The FIA’s planned restrictions on using the wings during the races have rightly drawn criticism.
The plan is the wings will only be used to promote overtaking. Drivers can only use them when they are within a second of the car in front, and then they can only used it in a pre-determined area on the track.
Many fans are concerned – and not just that it might make overtaking too easy. But also that F1 has become so fixated with increasing overtaking that it will hand a chasing driver an advantage not available to the driver they are trying to overtake to achieve it.
The counter-argument is that the leading driver already as an ‘unfair advantage’ – the enormous, turbulent flow of air spilling off the back of their car, creating a huge and invisible buffer to anyone trying to pass.
As F1 aerodynamics have become more refined in the decades since wings were first introduced, drivers have found it harder to use this disturbed air to gain a beneficial ‘tow’, and catch up to a car on the straights. At the same time the performance penalty of following another car closely in the corners has become even greater.
DRS, the argument goes, simply redresses the balance. But the key question is, when we see a driver use DRS to make a pass, will we still feel like they’ve earned it? I’m not sure we will.
DRS in the races: other problems
A further concern is the potential for misuse, opening yet another way for drivers to be handed penalties.
Perhaps the strangest aspect of the rules is that drivers may use them any time they are within a second of another car, regardless of how far behind they are in the race.
If Sebastian Vettel laps Narain Karthikeyan in Melbourne, the HRT driver will get to use his DRS if he is within a second of the Red Bull driver at the line.
It’s strange the FIA have decided to implement the rule in this way and you have to wonder if it’s because their system is not sophisticated enough to distinguish between cars that have been lapped.
Give DRS a chance
Happily the FIA has admitted the system may need fine-tuning and an allowance for them to make adjustments is written into the regulations.
We shouldn’t be too hasty to judge them and, as noted earlier, I expect the wings will be fantastic to see in qualifying.
Having said that, I think the proximity restriction is unnecessarily complicated and too much of a gimmick. It looks another example of FIA rule-making at its worst, up there with aggregate qualifying and fuel credits.
Simply rationing how many times a driver may use DRS during the race would be much easier to enforce, free of the taint of ‘gimmickry’, and quite possibly just as effective in promoting overtaking.
Yes, it would allow drivers to use their wings defensively – but spotting in your mirrors when the driver behind you as dropped his rear wing wouldn’t be that easy.
We’ll get our first indication of how much of a difference DRS will make next week.
What’s your take on DRS? Do you think it will make overtaking too easy? Are you bothered that it might be a ‘gimmick’? Have your say in the comments.
2011 F1 season preview
- The complete F1 Fanatic 2011 season preview
- The 2011 F1 season in 20 questions
- The 2011 F1 rules changes at-a-glance
- Which F1 races are you going to in 2011?
- DRS: Separating the good from the bad
- How new tyres will change F1 in 2011
- Waiting to win: When each F1 driver last won a race
- Rookies bring three countries back to F1
- Glock doubts Virgin will reach midfield in 2011
- Hard to see much progress for HRT in 2011
Browse all 2011 F1 season preview articles