Chandhok fears 2013 Indian GP could be the last

F1 Fanatic Round-up

Start, Buddh International Circuit, 2012In the round-up: Indian motorsport boss Vicky Chandhok is concerned India’s F1 race won’t come back after its year off in 2014.

Daniil Kvyat

Following Toro Rosso’s announcement that Daniil Kvyat will drive for them next year you can find F1 Fanatic’s biography of him here:

And if you’re a fan of Kvyat’s you can add him to your list of drivers you support. To update your favourite driver and team picks log in, select Edit My Profile from the top-right menu, then select F1 Teams and Drivers. Make your selection then click “Save Changes”.

Links

Your daily digest of F1 news, views, features and more.

Indian F1 Grand Prix on Sunday could be last, warns Vicky Chandhok (The Guardian)

“If we lose it, I would be very disappointed, because it took us ten years to get the race in the first place. It was in 1999 that Bernie Ecclestone first had talks with organisers and sponsors in India.”

UP government withdraws entertainment tax exemption to F1 (The Times of India)

“Four days before the third edition of India’s F1 race gets rolling at the Buddh International Circuit (BIC), the Uttar Pradesh government on Monday sought the Supreme Court’s permission to withdraw its 2011 decision to grant entertainment tax exemption to Indian Grand Prix organizer Jaypee Sports International.”

Di Resta faces uncertain Formula One future (Reuters)

“It’s tough because of circumstances that don’t help drivers that don’t have big funding. The team know knows what I can do. They gave me the tool to achieve what I can.”

McLaren: Hard work ahead with Honda (F1)

Jonathan Neale: “We’d be happy if [Peter Prodromou] was starting first thing tomorrow morning, but we do fully respect Red Bull’s position as we do when we’re recruiting anybody from another organisation.”

Looking beyond the F1 paddock (Carlin)

“There are a handful of drivers in each junior category, racing for various teams that are capable right now of racing in Formula One. That?s not to belittle what it takes to drive in Formula One. That?s highlighting how good these junior drivers are.”

Tweets

Comment of the day

WillP argues F1’s process of picking tracks for races is back-to-front.

The whole process is backwards.

If a country wants to run an F1 race these days, it needs to build a circuit. The circuit is given some land and it is created within the boundaries of the rules. That?s what we now end up with. Sometimes it is successful, sometimes not so.

In earlier years, a country would apply for an F1 race because it had a track – often a great track. But even if it wasn?t that great, it would often come about through a love of motor sport, an evolution of tarmac through the local terrain.

This is probably overly romantic but there is a point in there somewhere. You can?t force a natural track rhythm and atmosphere.
WillP

From the forum

Happy birthday!

Happy birthday to Manatcna!

If you want a birthday shout-out tell us when yours is by emailling me, using Twitter or adding to the list here.

On this day in F1

And happy birthday to Alessandro Zanardi who turns 47 today.

Image ?? Red Bull/Getty

Advert | Go Ad-free

54 comments on Chandhok fears 2013 Indian GP could be the last

  1. OmarR-Pepper (@omarr-pepper) said on 23rd October 2013, 0:05

    How long will DiResta keep claiming he has a har time? Deal with it!

    • OmarR-Pepper (@omarr-pepper) said on 23rd October 2013, 0:07

      har hard… and BTW, it’s also the press who keeps on this “rowing for our helpless child DiResta”

      • Hamish said on 23rd October 2013, 0:41

        I think he needs to understand it is quality of time, not quantity of time that moves you up in F1.

        The way he spoke about missing out on McLaren last year its almost as if he assumed that this would just be a natural progression…..and what do they say about assumptions?

    • celeste (@celeste) said on 23rd October 2013, 2:17

      i think he is preparing a PR strategy for the moment Force India fired him, more based on results than on his size or money from sporsonship.

  2. Broom (@brum55) said on 23rd October 2013, 0:14

    What a shame. I always enjoyed hearing how wonderful it was by the Beeb and Sky before sleeping through the race.

    • Nick (@nick-uk) said on 23rd October 2013, 8:02

      To be fair the circuit has a decent layout. I think to some extent the India GP is one of the victims of Red Bull and Vettel domination. The races have been snooze fests because of it.

      Then again, I guess there wasn’t even much mid field action either.

      • KaIIe (@kaiie) said on 23rd October 2013, 10:19

        In terms of racing, it’s a bit like a worse version of Korea: one really long straight and then two sectors where you just have to follow.

        Actually, I quite like the track, simply because it’s a bit shorter than the standard 5.5km.

      • Chalky (@chalky) said on 23rd October 2013, 11:25

        I believe it’s more of a victim of DRS. The circuit was most likely designed without the consideration of what DRS could do and then we all watch DRS pass after DRS pass on the long straight, like in Korea. Only a few well thought out KERS assisted passes have come about at other sections.
        Also, there probably is plenty of elevation but the camera angles used hardly give that impression. Surely some more variety of cameras can be used to make some better TV viewing? But then this is an issue at other circuits too.
        However, I don’t think new tracks should be completely dismissed for F1. You only have to look at CotA and see what a wonderful new track that is, so it’s certainly possible to get it right.

        • Nick (@nick-uk) said on 23rd October 2013, 18:03

          @chalky

          I agree the debut in Texas was excellent. But will it be repeated?

          The quality of a race is almost as much based on the situation for the drivers that day as it is the layout. For instance, after years of sleepy Sundays in Valencia and Abu Dahbi… along came two stunning races in 2012. Both had been flammed for being terrible circuits prior to that year, but if they had been debut events in 2012 and showed races like we had last year nobody would have criticised them.

          Conversely, Spa, Montreal and Silverstone are ofen regarded as some of the best tracks on the clendar. All of them have had their share of dull races.

  3. Jack (@jackisthestig) said on 23rd October 2013, 0:21

    Wasn’t Paul’s route into F1 built on ‘big funding’ from Mercedes?

    • toiago (@toiago) said on 23rd October 2013, 0:24

      I don’t know how far back the connection between Mercedes and Paul goes, but it certainly has been since his DTM days when he competed with a Mercedes car, even winning the championship in 2010, the year before getting signed up by Force India.

      • Hamish said on 23rd October 2013, 0:46

        …….because of Mercedes affiliation and backing. Whos the poor sucker he replaced – Tonio Liuzzi

        • mhop (@mhop) said on 23rd October 2013, 9:15

          Mercedes gave di Resta backing BECAUSE of his talent. Which is a totally different thing to someone getting in to F1 purely due to their nationality or wealthy background.

          Also are you saying that di Resta didn’t deserve that seat over Liuzzi? In 2009 Liuzzi — 5 years in to his F1 career — was nowhere near Sutil’s pace; in 2010 di Resta — coming straight from touring cars — equalled and often outpaced Sutil. I think di Resta was/is incomparably more talented than Liuzzi.

  4. LindaF1 said on 23rd October 2013, 1:29

    I think it will be a shame if the Indian Gp doesn’t return in the future, I don’t really get why this circuit is hated so much as its a nice circuit thats popular with the drivers & has produced fairly entertaining races the past 2 years.

    I also cannot understand why people say its produced boring races, Yes Vettel’s pretty much dominated both (Hardly the fault of the circuit, Just down to car/driver been better than anyone else on the day) but there has been plenty of good, close racing behind & both races have provided good levels of overtaking, 27 on-track overtakes in 2011 & 31 in 2012.

    Circuit layout is nice I think, The 1st few corners are interesting with the elevation & the long straght is made more interesting by the elevation. The wide entry into the proceeding turn 4 was done as per Driver/Team input, Turn 5 is fairly fast & the following double chicane at Turns 6-9 is another section done with driver input & is quite a fun little section. Turns 10-12 are fast & technical with a little banking adding to it & turns 13/14 are a fairly flowing. Turn 15 is a fairly straightforward bend but does have some elevation change to make it a bit more interesting & the final corner while nothing special isn’t so bad.

    • Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine) said on 23rd October 2013, 8:26

      produced fairly entertaining races the past 2 years

      Not a view shared by the majority I’m afraid. Of all the tracks to have held more than one race since 2008, Buddh has had the lowest average rating from readers:

      http://www.f1fanatic.co.uk/2013/06/26/your-view-on-the-last-100-races-analysed/#circuits

      Still I do think the tyre choices have probably been on the conservative side so that might change things this year.

      • LindaF1 said on 23rd October 2013, 15:24

        I know its got low ratings the last 2 seasons & that is what I honestly cannot understand because neither race has been dull unless your only looking at the race winner.

        In both 2011 & 2012 there was loads of great racing, Close battles, Some interesting incidents & as the stats show a decent amount of overtaking.

    • Steph (@stephanief1990) said on 23rd October 2013, 8:36

      @LindaF1 the races haven’t really been that great but loads of tracks which fans love usually produce boring races (Monza, Suzuka, Monaco, Silverstone) and the Indian race is still very young so it hasn’t been given a fair shot.

      I do love the track though – it’s fast, flowing and has some really challenging corners. I think it probably will disappear from the calendar but I’ll be really sad to see it go.

    • BasCB (@bascb) said on 23rd October 2013, 8:42

      I agree with you that it would be a shame to see India get dropped from the calendar, but certainly not for the great races there.

      – Its a shame because that is almost a billion potential fans to the sport (attendance was not the biggest problem for the event)
      – its a shame because someone invested hundreds of millions that now end up being wasted
      – its a shame because the reasons for it are the incredible change in the exchange rate that make it too expensive for the Indians to pay the fees and the uncooperative Authorities helping it further down the drain.

      The only Indian race I have been exited about was the first one. It was new, the track looked interesting and we did not know what to expect. After that, its one more race we can file under “ah Vettel will do a pole and win from there, what’s the action behind him look like” race.

      • LifeW12 (@lifew12) said on 23rd October 2013, 10:26

        Something like 90% of the Indian population lives on less than $5 a day, so its impossible for them to attend the race.

        A ticket for the Australian GP this year was $150 for 4 days walk around.

      • Funkyf1 (@funkyf1) said on 23rd October 2013, 12:23

        @BasCB I understand how you feel regarding thd Vettel domination at India, but unfortunately that seems to be occurring at more tracks than less now days. Like Steph and Linda I love the track, that doesn’t need to change, but you made some valid points all of which are controllable measures. My view on COTD I think reflects this. The new circuits have no atmosphere! Classics events have an aura, street circuits have a hype, modern day purpose built tracks have are generally dust bowls with stands. Shanghai, I think is a great circuit, but I couldn’t believe how run down and empty it felt when I was there this year, only the fans keep this sport alive. I know it’s the same old bang wagon I’m riding on, but fees need to be dropped, incentives and entertainment needs to bolstered (especially with the lack of running in everything but q3 and race now days) people need things to do in this time if they are going to pay good money for an event. @LifeW12 makes a good point, it you going to build a track in these environments and climates you must be in touch with the immediate climate. Anyhow I’ve now made this into a long draw out boring rant. On a closing note, maybe they could add some trees at the circuits. That would make them more attractive.

        • BasCB (@bascb) said on 23rd October 2013, 22:39

          I am not that sure its Vettel and Red Bull that are the problem here though. Sure, they have mastered the game of being fastest, then pulling a lead out and staying ahead.

          But I haven’t seen all that exiting action behind him either. I think the problem is rather the track that just does not work for current F1 @funkyf1.

  5. mantresx (@mantresx) said on 23rd October 2013, 2:47

    To the COTD, is also backwards in that drivers are put into F1 because there’s a race in their country not the other way around.
    Especially Sirotkin, as talented as he is, we wouldn’t even consider he could get a seat in F1 if it wasn’t for the race in Russia next year.

    • Prisoner Monkeys (@prisoner-monkeys) said on 23rd October 2013, 4:59

      @mantresx – Are you coming to that conclusion based on Sirotkin’s performances or Sirotkin’s results. On paper, he’s had a shocker, as he has been let down by poor machinery or on the receiving end of another driver’s silly moves. When he wad on form and the mechanical gremlins took the day off, Sirotkin was usually racing da Costa.

    • JCost (@jcost) said on 23rd October 2013, 7:43

      Very good blog post from Carlin. We talk about pay drivers in F1 but if we look down the ladder we will see loads of them but junior teams these days are well equipped and they really can nurse those kinds to glory. Plus, to be fair, there’s also a good amount of talent in GP2, GP3, WSR, F3 and other categories, it’s just a shame many of them are being left out, even some considered to be “slum dunks”…

  6. Michael Brown (@) said on 23rd October 2013, 2:57

    I hope McLaren realizes that they aren’t going to Korea

  7. Chris (@tophercheese21) said on 23rd October 2013, 3:38

    The Buddh circuit is probably one of the better Tilke circuits. The second sector is incredible.

    I hope it does make a return to the calendar in future years.

  8. Howard (@howard) said on 23rd October 2013, 3:41

    So why hasn’t a big team swooped up Di Resta if they know what he can do?

  9. Jonathan Neale: “We’d be happy if [Peter Prodromou] was starting first thing tomorrow morning, but we do fully respect Red Bull’s position as we do when we’re recruiting anybody from another organisation.”

    Made me laugh. It makes you believe that poaching other teams personnel is okay and standard. Oh Mclaren… Red Bull is the new Williams for them.

    • Optimaximal (@optimaximal) said on 23rd October 2013, 9:10

      They made an offer for Prodromou, he accepted pending his notice and inevitable gardening leave.

      Also, you cannot compare this to Adrian Newey’s moves – in both cases he voluntarily left he previous employer. Williams tried to stop him going to McLaren, he won and set the 6-months gardening leave precedent.

    • Poaching staff from other teams is completely normal and common. Not sure what you have an issue with? In fact it is not just F1 teams most companies will try to poach staff from competitors where especially when there is a shortage of highly skilled staff to fill the position. It is why many work contracts will specify gardening leave if moving to a competitor. There is certainly nothing unusual about it.

  10. Harvs (@harvs) said on 23rd October 2013, 6:13

    Are Mclaren planning on not wearing any pants in India?

  11. JCost (@jcost) said on 23rd October 2013, 7:27

    @keithcollantine you gotta fix the “The Guardian”

    Indian F1 Grand Prix on Sunday could be last, warns Vicky Chandhok (The Guarfian)

  12. Funkyf1 (@funkyf1) said on 23rd October 2013, 8:22

    Great COTD, modern tracks lack atmosphere regardless of their layout. As for Di Resta he’s had his chance, never rated him anyhow. Is his seat under threat because Lotus can’t guarantee The Hulk a seat and he might be going back?

  13. Red Andy (@red-andy) said on 23rd October 2013, 9:20

    On COTD, I understand the sentiment, but the parochial view of F1 as a predominantly European sport is unsustainable. The new markets are essential for the sport to maintain its global appeal and justify the quingigillions of dollars that are spent on it every year. You could argue for a somewhat cheaper model that places greater emphasis on staying on traditional circuits that are largely in western Europe, but you’d risk F1 losing its status as the pinnacle of world motorsport.

    It’s not a new phenomenon either – F1 has been pushing the boundaries into markets that might be considered lucrative for decades. Sometimes it pays off (e.g. Hungary, at the time an unprecedented foray behind the Iron Curtain) and sometimes it doesn’t (e.g. the Caesar’s Palace car park).

    It’s true that new venues often lack atmosphere, but a lot of that is down to local race promoters not doing enough to promote the event, or having ticket prices that are way beyond the means of the locals, or both. The hosting fees FOM charge are part of the story, but not necessarily the whole of it.

  14. sato113 (@sato113) said on 23rd October 2013, 10:15

    as keith says, i hope the softer tyres for this race will produce some excitement. the last races here have been so, soooo dull.

  15. LifeW12 (@lifew12) said on 23rd October 2013, 10:28

    Pity the track was built where it was, its not bad. Should have built it in South Africa.

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.