Alonso: Vergne should get penalty for pit exit incident

2013 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix

Fernando Alonso, Ferrari, Yas Marina, 2013Fernando Alonso believes Jean-Eric Vergne should be penalised following the incident between the pair during the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix.

Alonso came out of the pits near the Toro Rosso driver following his final pit stop, then went over the run-off at the exit of turn three to move ahead of Vergne.

Speaking to reporters after the race Alonso said: “Obviously it’s always a little bit of a question mark what [the stewards] will decide.”

“You need to leave a space always when you have a car alongside you. He didn’t give a space and I was forced to be out of the track so my opinion he should be penalised, in his opinion I overtake outside the track so we’ll see.”

Alonso believes he was unlikely to finish higher than he did given his qualifying position.

“Obviously we lost a lot of time in traffic but looking at the pole position, 20 seconds in front of us I think fifth was the maximum anyway, with or without traffic. So perfectly happy.

“One Mercedes in front, one behind. One Lotus in front, one behind. So minimised the championship, in the constructors’, loss.”

Update: No penalty for Alonso over Vergne incident

2013 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix

Browse all 2013 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix articles

Image ?é?® Ferrari/Ercole Colombo

Advert | Go Ad-free

87 comments on Alonso: Vergne should get penalty for pit exit incident

  1. OmarR-Pepper (@omarr-pepper) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:41

    April’s fool in November? I don’t buy that Fer

    • I dont think anybody forced you to buy anything :)

    • Gdon (@gdon) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:45

      Ok so no penalty for alonso and whatever is written below is rubbish!

    • By FIA driving standards, its perfectly legit to push others out of the track. If you dont gain position by pushing them out, stewards will give you that position because you pushed them out. Ask from Perez about details how to do it successfully. It works..

      Alonso´s penalty should be no brainer..

  2. Rossa (@rossa) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:43

    WHAT!?
    He overtook Vergne out off the track and asks the penalty for him!? his cheek has no limits! Teflonso!
    Hope the stewards will punish him!

    • Jorge Lardone (@jorge-lardone) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:59

      +1

      • Kingshark (@kingshark) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:00

        Vergne cut across him when he was exiting the pits, this incident is about as much Alonso’s fault as Hamilton vs Rosberg Bahrain 2012 was Lewis’ fault.

        • Imre (@f1mre) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:22

          When Hamilton overtook Rosberg outside of the track? That was an illegal pass.

        • Mads (@mads) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:31

          @kingshark
          Vergne took the racing line. This isn’t some flat out corner where the cars have enough grip to change direction on the exit. Once he has got on the gas he can’t do anything. Unless you want him to lift off the throttle, but since Alonso was behind, I don’t see why he should have done that.

          • Kingshark (@kingshark) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:33

            @mads
            If Vergne took the “racing line”, then why was he about 3 car widths wider than Massa behind him around that corner?

            Anyway, I have no idea how anyone could blame Alonso for this, he was only exiting the pits, and Vergne unnecessarily cut him off.

          • Eric (@) said on 3rd November 2013, 19:18

            @kingshark

            I have no idea how anyone could blame Alonso for this

            What a surprise.

    • BasCB (@bascb) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:56

      They didn’t penalize him.

      Why on earth they didn’t? Beats me. Surely Vergne isn’t the one who deserved a penalty there. Maybe its Ferrari thinking, they remembered when Bourdais got a penalty because Massa cut across him in 2008!

  3. As long as Vergne didn’t cut across the pit exit line whilst Alonso was there, I don’t see how that argument could hold water at all Alonso.

    • Kingshark (@kingshark) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:01

      @vettel1
      He did cut across, compare Massa’s line with Vergne’s line on the exit of the pits, you will see that Vergne deliberately took a much wider line to cut Alonso off.

      • Over the white line though and impeding Alonso @kingshark? Both would have to be true for Vergne to be considered in line for having a penalty.

        • Kingshark (@kingshark) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:32

          Over the white line though and impeding Alonso kingshark? Both would have to be true for Vergne to be considered in line for having a penalty.

          Yes, Vergne did cross the white line (pit-lane exit) and cut off out in front of Alonso.

          Vergne took a very shallow line through turn 3, and when you compare that to the very tight line taken by Massa, it became obvious that he was attempting to impede Alonso.

    • bananarama (@bananarama) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:04

      Imagine a car being alongside the other (doesn’t matter if completely or just next to rear wheel). When the driver who is being overtaken moves his car towards the track limits so the other car is being pushed out of the track and this happens in a straight, that is not allowed. If the same happens in a corner it is allowed. And if the driver being pushed out manages to still get ahead then getting ahead is not allowed. It is handled just like purposely deciding to take a line outside track limits in order to carry higher speed to overtake someone. Maybe there is no better way to make rules but to me this doesn’t seem ideal.

      Unsurprisingly I agree with Alonso that he was next to Vergne and had no space left but very likely he will still get a penalty but well this sort of things happen, racing with others is always riskier than breezing ahead ;)

    • Niki Lauda:” as a driver I would have done what Fernando did…..but you knever know what stewards do. ” I value his opinion more than most talking heads here.

  4. No Alonso, I think you’re the one who should be penalised.

  5. Nick (@npf1) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:45

    He didn’t give a space

    And all the time, you have to leave a space!

    Even though the pit exit prevents both the driver on the track and coming out of the pitlane of their usual view of the other driver. Let’s see what the stewards decide, based on their footage.

    • Stuart said on 3rd November 2013, 16:16

      I thought the rule was only about corner entry, you see drivers all the time push out the other car on corner exit.

  6. Red Andy (@red-andy) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:45

    “All the time you hafta leava space!”

    The thing is that this sort of thing is legal, even though it probably shouldn’t be. It would be dangerous if the tracks weren’t lined with acres of tarmac.

  7. TMF (@tmf42) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:46

    If ALO escapes a punishment then the FIA and the stewards reduce any point they tried to make during the season about track limits to a pointless joke.

  8. Juan Pablo Heidfeld (@juan-pablo-heidfeld-1) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:48

    Don’t think JEV should get a penalty, but neither should Alonso. Racing incident due to position of pit exit

  9. Diceman (@diceman) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:51

    Didn’t see that statement coming. If someone should get penalty form that situation it’s Alonso IMO.

  10. PhilEReid (@philereid) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:56

    No penalty either way for me. If this had nothing to do with the pit lane, and Alonso was in the position, then a penalty for Vergne would be just because there is the rule of always leaving a cars width on the outside if a car is there. No penalty for Alonso as he has been forced off. Nothing wrong on either part.

    • SpadXIII said on 3rd November 2013, 15:59

      To save face probably the FIA will issue a ineffective penalty (say 5 or 10 seconds) and be dono with it. There’s really no way for them to be consistent, in previous instances thaey have acted seemingly at random.

  11. palmerstoneroad (@palmerstoneroad) said on 3rd November 2013, 15:57

    Didn’t hear that in several Alonso’s interviews. Source?

  12. Guys, are you serious!?

    From the FIA F1 Driving protocol and penalties of 2013
    20.4 Any driver defending his position on a straight, and before any braking area, may use the full width of the track during his first move, provided no significant portion of the car attempting to pass is alongside his. Whilst defending in this way the driver may not leave the track without justifiable reason.
    For the avoidance of doubt, if any part of the front wing of the car attempting to pass is alongside the rear wheel of the car in front this will be deemed to be a ‘significant portion’.

    There is a moment, before leaving the track, where ALO is completely out of the pitlane, with all four wheels on track and exactly alongside VER.

    • Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:08

      If you re-read the full point you’ve quoted you’ll see why it doesn’t apply here:

      Any driver defending his position on a straight, and before any braking area, may use the full width of the track during his first move

      This is not what Vergne was doing – he was driving along the track on the racing line when Alonso appeared out of the pits. Vergne made no defensive moves, so he was not obliged to leave space.

      • scratt (@scratt) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:14

        It is arguable that Vergne would not have run that wide if he wasn´t “defending”.
        So I would still argue he made a defensive move, even though it was just gently running wide.

        • Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine) said on 3rd November 2013, 23:16

          @scratt

          It is arguable that Vergne would not have run that wide if he wasn’t “defending”.

          Which is irrelevant because the rule says:

          Any driver defending his position on a straight, and before any braking area

          Vergne was in a corner, not on a straight, nor was he approaching a braking area (not for another two corners, at least).

        • BasCB (@bascb) said on 4th November 2013, 6:40

          As Vergne himself has stated after the race, (explaining why HE did not think Alonso deserved a penalty) he was not making a defensive move at all @scratt.

          Instead, he expected Alonso to be close but because he did not see him, he thought Alonso was ahead of them, as he did not see him right behind. Therefore Vergne stayed on his line and was glad that Alonso took evasive action to avoid a collision.

      • This is not what Vergne was doing – he was driving along the track on the racing line when Alonso appeared out of the pits. Vergne made no defensive moves, so he was not obliged to leave space.

        If you have another car (as fast, if not faster than you) completely alongside you, and you push it off track… well, that is called “defending the position”.
        Maybe Vergne did not expect Alonso to be there, but Alonso couldn’t just disappear.

        • Kingshark (@kingshark) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:28

          @keithcollantine

          he was driving along the track on the racing line when Alonso appeared out of the pits. Vergne made no defensive moves, so he was not obliged to leave space.

          Vergne was not driving on the racing line and did make a deliberate move to block Alonso. Compare Vergne’s line to Massa’s line through that corner, and it becomes obvious that Vergne deliberately moved across to cut Alonso off.

          • Mads (@mads) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:36

            @kingshark
            You can’t compare them like that.
            Massa’s usual racing line isn’t necessarily the same as Vergne’s.
            If Massa lifted earlier then Vergne into the corner, then Massa would be able to take a tighter line on the exit. You have to look at Vergne’s previous laps and how he took that corner to know his racing line.

          • Sam (@) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:43

            He just took a lot of speed into that corner, If you’ve ever driven a car fast you know that in such a corner JEV really could not have turned more towards the inside of the corner on those old tyres.

          • Kingshark (@kingshark) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:47

            @mads and @ardenflo
            Even if (and that’s a big IF) Vergne’s awkward line through that corner was his normal racing line, then he still should have given at least some space to cars exiting the pits. It’s silly that JEV expected Alonso to just disappear.

          • Sam (@) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:49

            Cars on track always have the right of way over cars coming from the pits.

          • Mads (@mads) said on 3rd November 2013, 17:14

            @kingshark
            So Vergne should alter his racing line, on every single lap, because a car might exit the pits near him.
            But Alonso has every right to expect the Torro Rosso to suddenly gain infinite grip and just steer clear?
            It’s a corner that you commit to, and once you have done so and punched the throttle there is no backing out. The exit is entirely determined by the entry speed and line. And Vergne had every right to give it full banana going into that corner.

          • BasCB (@bascb) said on 4th November 2013, 6:41

            see my comment above @kingshark. Vergne had not seen Alonso right behind/next to him so he was taking his normal line through the corner instead of making room.

            No defensive driving (it was Massa who did see Alonso who left room, and was therefore not on the same line as Vergne)

      • Clearly your interpretation is not as accurate either, as you profess Keith.

  13. evered7 (@evered7) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:01

    Racing incident for me. If it is taking this long to come to a decision, then I believe they should give Alonso the benefit of doubt.

    It just means, it is not as clear cut as some believe it is.

    • SpadXIII said on 3rd November 2013, 16:07

      Fact is, Alonso was illegaly forced out of the track while he was overtaking Vergne, he had no choice but exit the track or crash. True, he could have given back the position afterwards but nobody told him to.

  14. kpcart said on 3rd November 2013, 16:04

    Alonso is right, and at the same time everyone with an opposing view is right. how can you decide such a pass on the exit of a pit lane? its not like other cases before where passing off the track was an advantage, this is a pass where the cars come out at the same point of the track and one has to go off track, its no advantage and their should be no penalty to either driver. Alonso could have spun out… and would have passed the opposing car the next lap anyway.

  15. evered7 (@evered7) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:08

    And while we talk about Alonso, why wasn’t Sutil penalised? No views on that matter?

    • Sam (@) said on 3rd November 2013, 16:45

      Nothing really.

      Sutil went wide, expected Maldonado to come back but he went wide too and stuck behind Perez who made a good move. What was Sutil supposed to do, let both pass again?

      • evered7 (@evered7) said on 3rd November 2013, 17:22

        Sutil was behind or in line with Maldonado. He didnt pass him on track. should have given the place to Maldonado and tried again. Instead he just straightened the corner and continued with the race.

        It doesn’t matter if Perez is in front now, that bad luck for Sutil. But he never passed Maldonado on track.

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.