Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, Shanghai International Circuit, 2014

Potential to increase engine noise ‘extremely limited’

2014 F1 seasonPosted on | Author Keith Collantine

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, Shanghai International Circuit, 2014Formula One engine designers warned the scope to increase the amount of noise produced by the current units is “extremely limited”.

The quieter sound of the new engines has been one of the talking points of the season with some fans regretting the loss of the louder V8s and commercial rights holder Bernie Ecclestone criticising the change.

The FIA has begun a consultation process to investigate what could be done to change the noise produced by the new V6 turbos. But Mercedes-Benz HPE engineering director Andy Cowell warned the configuration of the new units poses a major obstacle.

“The principal reason why the engine’s quieter is the turbine wheel and the muffling effect you get from that,” he said. “And perhaps one of the key technologies for recycling the waste eergy that would normal go down the tailpipe so it’s a key aspect of the technology we’ve got.”

“There are other things we can do, though, with the tailpipe, perhaps, to change the noise,” he added.

Renault Sport F1 deputy managing director Rob White said there was little opportunity to increase the volume produced by the current designs:

“The noise of the current engine is a consequence of the overall layout, the architecture and so forth.

“I think in terms of the possible adjustments to change the noise it makes I think we’re at the beginning of a consultative process that will kick off in about an hour’s time. Andy’s alluded to tailpipe changes, that’s something that could be a way to go.

“I think the scope to fundamentally and profoundly alter the noise of the engine is extremely limited by the type of technology that we have deployed. And therefore I think we need to be realistic about the scope of any action that we might take.

“But of course we’re sensitive to the subject and we’ll certainly participate in any of the studies that might lead to actions being taken.”

Cowell said increasing the current rev limit of 15,000rpm would not have an effect. “The fundamental reason is the fuel flow rate formula, so you get 100kg per hour once you’re at 10,500 rpm.”

“If you rev an engine faster you generate more friction and friction is the enemy of an engine and the enemy for a race car because you have to reject it to the radiators and there’s an aerodynamic deficit from doing that.

“None of us want to be below 10,500 but none of us want to be at high revs because all you do is create heat.”

2014 F1 season

Browse all 2014 F1 season articles

Image © Daimler/Hoch Zwei

43 comments on “Potential to increase engine noise ‘extremely limited’”

Jump to comment page: 1 2
  1. I have a solution. We add parts to restrict engine noise and add powerful speakers. Then, the teams are free to play whatever they want, V16s, V12s, V10s, V8s, Rolling Stones, whatever they want, as loud as they want.

  2. I’m tired of the constant bickering in F1. Scrap these stupid homologation rules. The best racing will come from engine development. This season is already a foregone conclusion hence. I won’t bother to watch. The Fia has now stuffed up we too.

  3. First time I ever head a f1 v10 scream by at 19k RPM it became clear to me that the noise was actually irrelevant, those things were far to noisy to be any fun, this was not about a noise for noise sake, but simply because it was the most efficient way.

    Likewise the lack of noise from the current engines should be irrelevant (it will take away some spectacle though, not sure thats good for f1, f1 has always been the reference sound for a truly angry racing car), what is not relevant however is that any petrol head can tell that these new packages are being short shifted all the way up and rarely run to their max and that is NOT the sound of pinnacle, need to drop that 100l/h rule and let the engines roll to the max.

Jump to comment page: 1 2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are moderated. See the Comment Policy and FAQ for more.