Group Admins

  • Profile picture of Keith Collantine

Group Mods

  • Profile picture of Estesark

F1 Fanatic site development

Public Group active 2 weeks, 6 days ago

A place for you to suggest technical changes for the site and request new groups

F1 Fanatic reader feedback August 2012: Content

Tagged: 

This topic contains 29 replies, has 22 voices, and was last updated by Avatar of Keith Collantine Keith Collantine 2 years ago.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 30 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #206678
    Avatar of snowman
    snowman
    Member

    Just a note on the form guide. When adding the qualifying head to head between team-mates it would be much more beneficial to compile it before penalties are added. You don’t really see who is winning the battle on quicker over one lap when penalties are added which makes it not really a true form guide.

    #206679
    Avatar of electrolite
    electrolite
    Participant

    There should definitely be a ‘headline’ system, almost like newspapers do. So a certain story almost gets pinned up at the top, the round-up for that particular day maybe at the side, and so on. There’s often times where I’ll have not viewed the site or had access to the internet for the day, and I feel as if I’ve already missed the good stuff which disappears to the bottom or goes on the next page. More often than not during the race weekend.

    #206680
    Avatar of Keith Collantine
    Keith Collantine
    Keymaster

    Thanks for the freedback so far everyone though for the most part it seems to be on technical stuff rather than the articles themselves. All useful though.

    @girts

    I’ve been asked about a podcast before and while I’d like to do one, the cost involving in producing one to a worthwhile standard would be high and it would be difficult to raise revenue from it. Most likely it would require sponsorship. Without that I can’t see it happening I’m afraid.

    Points atken about the quizzes, I’ll bear it in mind for future ones.

    @verstappen @daniel-chico @Electrolite

    Some useful points from all of you, particularly on how to make it easier for readers to make sure they haven’t missed anything.

    @sato113

    The ‘lap 1 positions gained/lost’ table went because I needed to reduce the amount of time spent on post-race analysis (see here: Race weekend articles on F1 Fanatic in 2012) and it basically duplicates information that’s already in the lap chart.

    The yearly average lap one position change is available in statistics, I may look into adding race-by-race data there:

    Position change on lap one

    @brad-ferrari There are next/previous image options underneath every picture. See here:

    http://www.f1fanatic.co.uk/2012/08/06/f1-fanatic-roundup-068/david-coulthard-action-10/

    @squaregoldfish

    One thing that gets me every time on the round-ups – the quotes from the articles you use are frequently nothing to do with the headlines of those articles.

    A fair point, though that’s because I sometimes consider the quote I’ve used to be more interesting than what the sub-editor for the publication in question has highlighted in the headline. I’ll have a think about a more elegant way of doing this.

    @snowman Yes we definitely need a clear distinction between ‘qualifying results’ and ‘starting order’.

    #206681
    Avatar of ECWDanSelby
    ECWDanSelby
    Participant

    I’d like to see more ‘Changing Tracks’ was it..? The feature about how tracks have changed over the years. Mega enjoyed them.

    Also Keith, not sure if it’d help at all but i’m happy to discuss any ideas for a podcast if you needed a hand?

    Cheers,
    Dan

    #206682
    Avatar of Keith Collantine
    Keith Collantine
    Keymaster

    @ECWDanSelby I’ll keep you in mind if it ever happens but without a sponsor it’s not going to.

    #206683
    Avatar of James A
    James A
    Member

    Hi,

    I would like to see more Technical Analysis, Why things are designed that way rather than an alternative way, more diagrams with arrows of before and after pictures…

    Also what is used to do all the illustrations ?

    #206684
    Avatar of
    Anonymous

    Perhaps a section of F1 supporting races (GP2, GP3) could be implemented or at least an article referring to the action besides the glitter of F1…

    #206685
    Avatar of Ral
    Ral
    Member

    The only thing I would say, is I find the after-race reporting a little too segmented. For example, the bottom 3 articles on page 3 of the news articles are currently:
    - 2012 Hungarian Grand Prix fastest laps
    - 2012 Hungarian Grand Prix lap chart
    -2012 Hungarian Grand Prix tyre strategies and pit stops

    While they are valid topics, they are also all inextricably linked to one another to the point where sometimes I am expecting information in one article that then seems to be kind of artificially left out because it does not strictly speaking come under the nominal header. It also leaves the associated comments strangely disconnected at times and me with trouble deciding where to leave certain comments I would like to make.

    I am not sure if you do this because it is easier to reference later on this way, or for performance issues, so I don’t know if this is something that you could viably address if you even wanted to. It is entirely possible that all of this is purely in my head, so feel free to take this with as much salt is you see fit :)

    #206686
    Avatar of BasCB
    BasCB
    Participant

    I recognize part of what @ral mentions here. It would be nice to have an easier way of somehow grouping these race analyses pages in the articles overview, like having a tab for last race and be able to select an overview of all pre race, or race analyses articles for a given race in the season as that would make it easier to keep an overview of whats there and enjoy absorbing all that great information.

    #206687
    Avatar of Keith Collantine
    Keith Collantine
    Keymaster

    @dimitris-1395 I do remarks on the GP2 races in the forum if I can find time (see here). But articles and features on non-F1 races on the site tend to perform much less well. There’s only a limited amount of work I can do, especially on race weekends, and F1 has to come first.

    This doesn’t mean I won’t do any – we had one last week – but committing to an increase would simply not be cost-effective.

    #206688
    Avatar of ShaneB457
    ShaneB457
    Participant

    @keithcollantine Have you ever considered letting people have signatures?

    #206689
    Avatar of Ral
    Ral
    Member

    Oh, please don’t do the signatures thing. Pretty please with all the cherries in the world on top and just liters and liters of whipped cream.

    #206690
    Avatar of matt90
    matt90
    Participant

    Yeah I second Ral.

    #206691
    Avatar of xbx-117
    xbx-117
    Participant

    Agreed, no signatures please.

    #206692
    Avatar of Keith Collantine
    Keith Collantine
    Keymaster

    @Ral I’m not 100% happy with how this works at the moment either. It an unsatisfactory compromise between offering the information in a useful form immediately after the race and in the archive. It was changed for this year and I expect I’ll change it again for next year. If anyone has suggestions on how then please share them!

    @mrjames12 The technical analysis articles and illustrations are done by @jonh-beamer

    @ECWDanSelby I think we’ve now got those for all the current tracks where significant changes have taken place. There’s also this earlier series:

    F1 circuits history part 1: 1950
    F1 circuits history part 2: 1951-3
    F1 circuits history part 3: 1954-7
    F1 circuits history part 4: 1958-60
    F1 circuits history part 5: 1961-6
    F1 circuits history part 6: 1967-70
    F1 circuits history part 7: 1971-4
    F1 circuits history part 8: 1975-8
    F1 circuits history part 9: 1979-84
    F1 circuits history part 10: 1985-9
    F1 circuits history part 11: 1990-3
    F1 circuits history part 12: 1994
    F1 circuits history part 13: 1995-8
    F1 circuits history part 14: 1999-2002
    F1 circuits history part 15: 2003-2007
    F1 circuits history part 16: 2008 and beyond

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 30 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.