F1 Fanatic

OK. So it’s pretty much become a well-accepted fact amongst most F1 fans that Hamilton, Vettel, and Alonso are the three best drivers in Formula One today. Virtually 99% of all non-biased fans would agree on this. In what order these drivers rank from 1-3 is very debatable and is down to personal opinion. You can make a strong case in favour of any of these three drivers.

Button was certainly a part of this group at the end of last year, but this season for him has been abysmal to say the least, much more for a driver with his reputation. Hell, Massa’s done better than him and out-scored him Bahrain onwards.

So, who do you think is the #4 driver in Formula One at the moment?

I am expecting the front-running candidates for this thread to be Webber, Rosberg, Raikkonen and Schumacher.

Yes, I think Raikkonen is every bit as good as the other 3 when he wants to be, but probably not at the moment, so I’ll put him 4.
Then Webber, Rosberg and Button in no particular order.

We’re already starting to talk about drivers being good when they’re “on form”, when they “want to be”, or when they are “happy with the car”. The top three drivers rarely, if ever have those caveats applied to them, which I suppose is what sets them apart. But is there really not a fourth driver who can get the most out of a car no matter what?

I can’t say that there are any outstanding candidates, but that’s what we should be thinking about when trying to make this decision. As well as raw speed, of course. Heikki Kovalainen is one of the most consistent performers around but I don’t think he’s even in the top ten in terms of pace. I suppose I would have to nominate Nico Rosberg. Romain Grosjean is looking very promising as well, but I think it’s a little early to comment on his consistency, especially with the mistakes he made at the beginning of the season.

Grosjean is getting there…..

@Kingshark I wasn’t saying it was an excuse – I was saying that Button has too small a sweet spot (in terms of car balance) to truly be considered anywhere near the top 3 names you’ve mentioned. ie I was completely agreeing with you.

I think Webber is quite underrated at times. He’s very inconsistent at times, but when he’s on it, he’s REALLY on it. I mean, fighting for the podium and/or victory in 2005 and 2006 Monaco in that sh*tbox Williams? Putting the 2004 Jaguar almost on pole in Malaysia? That has to count for something. Personally I think when he’s on form, he’s maybe in the top 5. Not very close to the top 3, but still in the top 5, if that makes sense. but he’s too inconsistent usually. I mean, spending all those laps stuck behind a Force India in Barcelona, one week before a fantastic Monaco performance.

A bit like Raikkonen in that sense – in that he’s mentally inconsistent. Mind you I still rate Raikkonen above Webber (on form Raikkonen beats on form Webber, off form Raikkonen beats off form Webber).

I realise that Rosberg is a popular choice around here – but I just still don’t see it. I’ve never been truly convinced of Rosberg sadly.

@Kingshark I don’t think it’s clear cut about 2010. There were many times Mercedes was quicker than the Renault, many times Renault were quicker.