Group Admins

  • Profile picture of Keith Collantine

Group Mods

  • Profile picture of damonsmedley
  • Profile picture of Bradley Downton

F1

Public Group active 1 hour, 27 minutes ago

F1 discussion

Button passed Hamilton on points

This topic contains 31 replies, has 22 voices, and was last updated by Profile photo of Aled Davies Aled Davies 2 years ago.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 32 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #132424
    Profile photo of magon4
    magon4
    Participant

    In their three years together at McLaren, Button ended up with 15 more points than Hamilton, if I’m not mistaken. This is curious, since Hamilton is clearly the better driver. Is is just down to bad luck?

    And McLaren ending the season in 3rd ist pretty desgraceful, I must say. Over the year, they certainly had the best car…

    #215741
    Profile photo of Bob
    Bob
    Participant

    The general consensus is that, in terms of driving skill, Hamilton outperformed Button in 2010 and 2012, and that Button outperformed Hamilton in 2011. The points are skewed somewhat by Hamilton’s far more numerous mechanical retirements and race incidents. Taking that into account, I would say Hamilton was the better McLaren driver overall for the duration of their three-year partnership, with Button not too far behind.

    And yes, it is utterly disgraceful that McLaren are third in the constructors’. On numerous occasions this season, they’ve had a clear performance advantage, yet have squandered it with operational errors and mechanical gremlins. Hamilton had Singapore and Abu Dhabi in the bag, and the car let him down. Button’s mid-season slump certainly didn’t help either.

    On a related note, Button’s win now means that McLaren have scored points in every single race since Bahrain 2010, the beginning of the Hamilton/Button partnership.

    #215742
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous

    @magon4

    Well, you are correct sir. The numbers can speak all they want but real fans know that Button was not superior to Hamilton. Anyways… Button passing Hamilton on points is not the only passing that took place today… I find it totally disgusting how Michael just opened a huge door for Sebastian…. and not to mention the Steward´s complicity in all this… take a look at this image… it´s amazing nobody has said anything about it…

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/90519586@N08/8217108275/in/photostream

    #215743
    Profile photo of Felipe Bomeny
    Felipe Bomeny
    Participant

    @catracho504 that yellow light does not indicate a yellow flag; it was merely pointing out slippery conditions. Ferrari presented this to Charlie Whiting, arguing that it was an illegal pass under yellow flags. Whiting ruled that Vettel’s pass on Kobayashi was not under yellow flags and it was perfectly legal.

    #215744
    Profile photo of Todfod
    Todfod
    Participant

    @JB . I was absolutely furious when I saw Schumi just let Vettel by. This is a WDC deciding race.. and I didn’t expect any favouritism from anyone other than your teammate in this race. I think it was disgusting of Schumacher to do so.. and even embarrassing for him not to race the world champ in his last race.

    #215745
    Profile photo of Calum
    Calum
    Participant

    Hamilton beat Button in two of the three seasons.
    Hamilton had more pole positions, more wins, and better qualifying overall.
    Button scored the most points, and took more podiums.

    Jenson referred to the team’s season as having lots of ups and downs: 3rd place in the constructors from a car on the front row in more than half the races and one which took 7 wins just shows how bad the downs were, very costly. Hamilton (Abu Dhabi, Singapore, Brazil, Spain) and Button (Monza) hit the team hard, the poor pitstops in the first half of the season didn’t help either.

    #215746
    Profile photo of Todfod
    Todfod
    Participant

    @magon4 . I really do not understand the point of this thread. I think every f1 fan will admit that Button was no match for Hamilton.

    #215747
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous

    @todfod

    I agree with you sir…. not a very gacious way to bow out…. I suddenly feel betrayed by Schumi after being in his side for a loooong time. The only legitimate help the title rivals could have was from their own team mates. But of course.. we all know RBR is a 4 man team… FIA really should do something about that… I think it was VERGNE or RICCIARDO that let both Webber wn Vettel by at some point…

    @portugoose
    Oh ok… if you say so… I was just under the impression that YELLOW is YELLOW and it means caution, no overtaking… you can also see another yellow in the mid part of the straight…. I guess this time the Stewards had the RBR rulebook and not the FIA book on hand.

    #215748
    Profile photo of Olivier42
    Olivier42
    Participant

    @catracho504 why are you derailing this thread about Button and Hamilton with incorrect information and conspiracy theories about Vettel and Red Bull?

    #215749
    Profile photo of magon4
    magon4
    Participant

    @Todfod I guess people should give Button more credit.
    And maybe, just maybe, some fans overestimate Hamilton’s overall abilities as an F1 driver. In three years, the possibly best driver on the grid should have a good difference to his team mate, and questions might be asked about HAM’s skill. He is fast, but is that all there is to the job?

    #215751
    Profile photo of infernojim
    infernojim
    Participant

    I think this spell between Button and Hamilton has done a great deal for Button’s reputation, and also for Hamilton’s maturity.

    Button has proven that he IS in the upper leagues of F1, and whilst on balance he has been outperformed by Hamilton in terms of race results, the fact that he was close in 2010 and 2012 and beat him in 2011 has been the making of him (an odd statement for someone who came to the team as WDC I know!).

    It’ll be really interesting to see how Button gets on next season as the true #1 driver in what should be a car that starts off as a race winner, along with Red Bull (based on current form and the fact that very little changes in the regs next season).

    For Hamilton, he’s driven his tits off this season, and been a lot more mature and likeable this season as well. The move to Mercedes seems a little foolish, but now is the first time in his career that I feel like he has the temperament and maturity to go and drag a team up the grid and mould it around him. He’s unlikely to challenge for the title next season, but fair play to him for giving it a go.

    #215752
    Profile photo of Bosley
    Bosley
    Participant

    Lewis: 240 + 227 + 190 = 657
    Jenson: 214 + 270 + 188 = 672

    So, from the 3 years we can see that in 2010, Lewis beat Jenson; in 2011, Jenson easily beat Lewis, and finally at the end of this year, it’s a 2 point difference meaning they basically tied, although yes technically Lewis won.

    So, if we think of it as Lewis beating Jenson at 2 years of being at the team, surely he should have had a higher points tally, but i guess that further proves how dominant and successful Jenson was in 2011, and how unlucky Lewis has been this year.

    #215753
    Profile photo of Thecollaroyboys
    Thecollaroyboys
    Participant

    Vettel was quicker than Shuey by at least a second. Vet was going to get past and perhaps Shuey didn’t want to get clipped by the crash kid and end his 20 year career in the tyre wall. Other than that, get over it.

    #215754
    Profile photo of Kingshark
    Kingshark
    Participant

    I do agree that Hamilton is the better one of the two. But for anyone who says Button is nothing but an average driver while Hamilton is a racing god, I hope these 3 years earned Jenson some respect.

    #215755
    Profile photo of Nick
    Nick
    Participant

    Lewis: 240 + 227 + 190 = 657
    Jenson: 214 + 270 + 188 = 672

    Madness how well the McLaren has been performing (when in the zone) but still scoring that many points less than in 2011 or even 2010.

    As for the topic: I think Hamilton has more raw speed and talent, but Button has a lot of experience and is a pretty quick driver as well, who, for multiple reasons, ended up with his McLaren in one piece more often than Lewis the past 2 seasons.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 32 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.