Group Admins

  • Profile picture of Keith Collantine

Group Mods

  • Profile picture of damonsmedley
  • Profile picture of Bradley Downton

F1

Public Group active 3 minutes ago

F1 discussion

Lee McKenzie verdict..?

This topic contains 34 replies, has 23 voices, and was last updated by Avatar of  Anonymous 3 years, 10 months ago.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 35 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #128188
    Avatar of Hare
    Hare
    Participant

    An obvious topic of conversation, how do we think she did on her first weekend hosting the F1 live coverage?

    #147208
    Avatar of
    Anonymous

    Very well. Ok she called Eddie Jordan Eddie James and Whitmarsh Martin Whittaker but to be plonked on the live stage presenting with EJ is a tough task. She had the worst job in the world yesterday when the rain came because nothing at all happened and that’s so much harder to deal with than when everything is going on at once. She had good control over the boys, presented well, covered the issues and did it in good style. She may have stumbled over the words from time to time but it was her first time presenting like that. Great job.

    #147209
    Avatar of VettelS
    VettelS
    Member

    I’ve never been too keen on her really. She’s okay with the interviews, but I wouldn’t like her doing the regular hosting.

    Steph said that it’s her first time, and that’s why she messed up quite a bit, but really the only difference is that she’s being filmed. A lot of the time she’s not actually on camera, but really, how different can it be? It’s still live, and it’s still F1.

    But even if she did it without the mistakes, I prefer Jake. I’m not sure if that’s because he’s better, or it’s purely preference, all know is that she’s only temporary.

    #147210
    Avatar of
    Anonymous

    I think it’s quite different personally. For a start there’s a lot more to do and millions of poeple watching you with a camera staring at you, you’ve got EJ and co. who have all really bonded together and found their own rhythm and it’s a totally new dynamic and before she asked the questions and relied on the driver so the less we saw of her the better but although this is similar she’s a lot more in the focus making the debate move on and forward, getting the fans views across etc. After just interviewing and digging for stories for so long it must be quite different having the stories brought to you and disecting them.

    I feel a bit sorry for her as it was her first time so maybe I’m biased but I thought she handled it well.

    #147211
    Avatar of Icthyes
    Icthyes
    Participant

    I really liked her. It was her first time and she would have been nervous. If Jake was ever to leave she’d be the right choice to step in, even if only initially.

    #147212
    Avatar of TommyB
    TommyB
    Participant

    She has no charisma and made a lot of mistakes.

    To be fair she had to put up with a lot. Cancelled Qualifying and the live feed going down.

    Looking forward to Jake returning. Would like Holly to replace Lee as pit reporter too.

    #147213

    I’m with Tommy. She had a lot of unusual stuff to deal with, from two qualifying sessions and a Virgin crashing live before the race.

    #147214
    Avatar of Hairs
    Hairs
    Participant

    First time on the job, I’d give her a good solid 8. A few mistakes, some dear air and mis-timed her talkovers on the VT’s a bit, but overall she coped well, kept things flowing, had a few moments of good charm too. Jake was very good from day 1, but he also had a few “moments” in his first few races too.

    The TV problems losing audio and video were interesting – I was on the Red Button, and had to decamp to normal TV to get video back, but the 5 live audio was still on. Then all of a sudden the “main” audio feed came back and it really was jolting. Normally you listen to one or the other, but the difference was just startling – there was just dead silence for minutes at a time. There was no charisma, no cameraderie, no interest, nothing. Martin made a few attempts at something interesting, but it went absolutely nowhere. It was like there was a dead cold sink in the room draining it of all interest. I’m not just saying that as an ardent hater of Legard’s commentary, but the producers can’t be unaware of the massive gulf in quality.

    #147215
    Avatar of Scribe
    Scribe
    Participant

    I agree, I prefer Holly and I don’t think Lee was very good. Didn’t feel warm, no Sue Barker, which is a rubbish comparison I know.

    The Beebs F1 set up has a weird habbit of giving less talented people the more important jobs. Holly Sammos and Sarah Holt are both more interesting reporters and frankly more fun then Lee “Bitterly Dissapointed” Mackenzie, but just don’t get the screen time, despite how good Holly is as a pit reporter for 5live.

    Sort of simular to the Legard Croft situation.

    #147216
    Avatar of Ned Flanders
    Ned Flanders
    Participant

    She seemed unbelievably nervous. She was swaying all over the place, getting people’s names mixed up, losing tack of what she was talking about, losing confidence in what she was saying halfway through sentences etc. In the brief moments that she composed herself I though she was OK, but if she can’t handle live TV then it isn’t the job for her.

    Incidentally, I thought Holly Samos did well on TV. She has a far more engaging voice, asks interesting questions and she seems to have a good rapport with the drivers

    #147217
    Avatar of Red Andy
    Red Andy
    Participant

    I was bitterly disappointed.

    (Not really, but I really wanted to say that).

    #147218
    Avatar of sw6569
    sw6569
    Participant

    Ted would have been a much better anchor this weekend.

    Lee unfortunately was not great. She’s somewhere in between being a motorsports enthusiast and a presenter – and in my opinion isn’t very good at either of those roles as a result. She reminded me of the itv coverage

    Jake is great as he is simply a great anchor with an understanding of motorsport.

    #147219
    Avatar of sbl on tour
    sbl on tour
    Participant

    come back jake , dont know why he had to do the games, think i,ve only seen him twice , playing second fiddle to ms barker

    what a waste (as ian dury would say)

    #147220
    Avatar of Woffin
    Woffin
    Member

    I think Jake’s gone to do the Commonwealth games in the hope that he makes a good impression on the big bosses who are already planning the London Olympic coverage…

    As for Lee, she did a solid job I think. Didn’t seem to give the broadcast the same life that Jake does and I can’t quite put my finger on why, but I guess that Jake is just a lot more natural and comfortable in the lead role after nearly two years doing it.

    And finally, as Hairs and Scribe have pointed out, I hope that Legard gets replaced by Croft for next season. Having the BBC1 commentary and 5Live commentary back to back really highlighted how poor and disjointed the main feed is. Many people will have heard Croft for the first time today (the casual viewers who just watch BBC1 or maybe the people who can’t be bothered/dont know what the red button offers) and I’m sure they would have noticed the difference in quality of commentary too. Brundle is being suffocated and is a shadow of his former self in the box, but with him and Kravitz on the main feed (and also the bad sync between the 5live audio and live picture) I find it hard to switch to the alternative commentary for the entire race and find myself having to put up with Legard, and his uninspiring repetitive drivel.

    #147221
    Avatar of squaregoldfish
    squaregoldfish
    Participant

    Live broadcasting takes a lot of getting used to – if you haven’t seen it, watch Jake’s video showing the first 20 minutes of the Singapore GP coverage:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/jakehumphrey/2010/09/what_its_like_being_an_f1_pres.html

    I’m guessing that Lee has barely any experience of that kind of work, so it’s not surprising there were a few mistakes. I know I couldn’t handle it. As a first/early attempt, she did a pretty good job. With more experience she’d improve no end, and more of her personality would come through.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 35 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.