Petrov as barometer for Heidfeld? (25 posts)

  • Profile picture of Ral Ral said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    I just hope Jake Humphry and Eddie Jordan will stop going on and on and on about “what if Kubica had been here” already. He isn’t. Let it go. Petrov is and he’s done an absolutely brilliant job for Renault this weekend. Let’s go with that going forward, eh?

  • Profile picture of pepsiperfect pepsiperfect said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    Re: I doubt Kimi and Renault will happen…
    >I am with U there dude
    but I do expect there to be a lot of noise in the media about the possibility, the chances of him returning to Ferrari to partner Alonso….
    >Again another good point, there will always B the speculation though
    I don`t see Ferrari droppin Massa.
    Hasnt Kimis contract with Ferrari ended?? (paid off …)
    Kimi is not the development driver Ferrari need. The flyin Finn(2) is fast though NOT what Ferrari need at the mo, neither is Alonso. Ferrari need 2 develop the CAR. Alonso will be consistent in what ever. Kimi will be flyin fast in whatever.

  • Profile picture of Deleted User said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    Heidfeld had a great start but suffered a fair bit of damage (Ads posted thyis http://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/110930477/AFP)and didn’t have KERS. So he wasn’t great but he had a hell of a difficult time too.

  • Profile picture of butterdori butterdori said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    That’s pretty severe. Why didn’t he retire?

  • Profile picture of Hare Hare said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    Heidfeld is much faster and smarter driver than Petrov.

    But he didn’t finish 3rd did he!! PWND! :)

    ( let it be known, I’m a Petrov fan as of now )

  • Profile picture of BasCB BasCB said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    Nice idea for taking Petrov as a Constant. But it won’t work as Petrov does not seem to be that constant at all. Last year he showed speed but a lot of mistakes and inconsistancy.

    Now he seems to have kept the speed and the marvellous starts but no mistakes so far.

    Heidfeld certainly did not impress all weekend. But its hard to judge how bad his KERS hampered him in Qualli (not that it excuses him being over a second slower) and he might have done a bit more in the race if he had not got hit that much damage.
    Looks like Renault kept him in the race only to gather some data on reliability. I must say I am supprised they did not overheat with the exhausts fitted in there underneath.

  • Profile picture of Andy W Andy W said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    I love how people try to make huge statements about drivers based on the back of one race, or their rookie season… The thing about rookies is that they are often inconsistent, they often make ‘school boy’ errors…. thats what it means to be a rookie for crying out loud.

    Petrov put down a marker at Melbourne, he has set a high bar for himself and for the team, as well as his team mate Heidfeld. Its not like Petrov fluked his qualifying position or managed to score a lucky podium because of a safety car. He beat Heidfeld in practice, he looked comfortable and confident in the car all weekend.

    Yes he may have been driving out of his skin, actually he was… but he drove that race he qualified the car at the sharp end of the grid, he made up positions with his start and he defended against both Webber and Alonso several times during the race whilst still looking after his tyres so he was able to stop 1 time less than either of them….

    Don’t blame the tyres thou… take a look at Alonso strategy soft, soft, soft, hard… Alonso had to make his 3rd stop to use both compounds of tyres… this was a strategy decision. Webber was the 1st driver to stop for new tyres (without having had a puncture or an off).

    Heidfeld on the other hand had a stinker of a weekend, and I am sure Renault did keep him out long after they had given up hope on him scoring any points, simply so they could get the extra testing mileage on the car. However at no point during the weekend did Heidfeld look like the dominant team mate that many of us expected him to be, this is a guy who kept Kubica, Massa and Kimi all honest when he was partnered with them. I just want to see how he performs at Malaysia, can he raise his game and put Petrov under pressure, for that matter can Petrov take the form he showed this weekend and keep his Renault at the sharp end of the grid and compete for podiums, can he reach that bit higher and compete for race wins? Probably not given how dominant the Red Bull looks and McLaren did seem to have a good step more pace… but we all know the sport and we all know that cars capable of competing for podiums can win if the circumstances are right.

  • Profile picture of cubejam cubejam said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    I’ve noticed how unfairly he gets treated on the Renault facebook page. By these apparent Renault fans…. Almost as if they think he stole Kubicas seat or something..

    I’d say It’s best to compare both against each other.

  • Profile picture of Jay_au Jay_au said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    (Heidfeld had a great start but suffered a fair bit of damage…)

    Glad to hear there may have been a reason for his lack of pace. As a fan, I was bitterly disappointed to see him lapped but his teammate, which from memory may have been as early as lap 45(?).

  • Profile picture of Adam Tate Adam Tate said 2 years, 1 month ago:

    Kimi to partner Alonso would be nice, just as a way of proving once and for all that Kimi is quicker :)

    Otherwise I’d hate Massa to be shoved aside, much like Heidfeld he doesn’t get enough credit.

You need to log in to create and reply to topics. You can log in with your F1 Fanatic account here or sign up for an F1 Fanatic account here.

Advert | Go Ad-free