Should points be awarded for pole and fastest lap?

This topic contains 15 replies, has 15 voices, and was last updated by Profile photo of Fixy Fixy 4 years ago.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • Author
  • #130152
    Profile photo of Felipe Bomeny
    Felipe Bomeny

    This is pretty straightforward; points are allocated to drivers in junior formulae for fastest lap/pole position. What if this was to come to Formula One? Obviously points for pole may be unfair if there is one dominant qualifting car (cough, Red Bull, cough) but a point for fastest lap could create great last-lap racing- and drama, as drivers would scramble at the closing stages to nab an important extra point.

    Profile photo of raymondu999

    Or it could also block out overtakes; a la Vettel in the middle of 2010. He used to back out massively at the penultimate lap and put in a pole-blinding effort on the last lap to nab fastest lap

    Profile photo of Keith Collantine
    Keith Collantine
    Profile photo of KaIIe

    No. With the current economy, how good would it look if half the field would pit with few laps to go for fresh tyres just for one silly point?

    Profile photo of Enigma

    Vettel’s title lead is the perfect example why that’s a bad idea – perhaps he would go to Suzuka qualy with engine mapping set in a way that the car would give up after 5 laps, as he’d only need pole to win the title. That’d be terrible.

    The fastest lap point is much worse than the pole position point though – everyone’s going for pole anyway, plus they’re all on low fuel. The fastest lap point would be even worse, much worse.

    Profile photo of safeeuropeanhome

    I don’t think it should ever be introduced to Formula One. This kind of thing works in formulae like touring cars, or lower down single seaters because the cars tend to be more even across the field and races are much shorter so there is no stopping for new tyres which is obviously a big advantage. Also in things like touring cars they have the ballast system to even out performance so different cars have a chance of getting it each weekend.

    It just wouldn’t work in Formula One.

    Profile photo of matt90

    This came up fairly recently on the forum. I said if only point-scorers were eligible for a fastest lap point then it would relieve some of the silly situations that could arise. After all, nobody in the points will pit for fresh tyres as they’ll most likely lose position which will cost them at least as much as the single point for fastest lap. And now that a win is worth 25 points, giving away a single additional point for either fastest lap or pole doesn’t have as much affect as it used to.

    Profile photo of wasiF1

    For pole I think they can.

    Profile photo of Journeyer

    Nope. It’s not broken, so what’s there to fix?

    Profile photo of PJ

    How about constructors points (10,9,8.. 1) for those that make Q3?

    Drivers points, no.

    Profile photo of Ratboy

    I think not, without doing the maths on it I think Vettel would already be champion, mind he pretty much is now anyway

    Profile photo of Girts

    It is an option. In NASCAR, points are awarded for leading at least one lap and for leading the most laps, too.

    However, I think the championship should never be decided on Saturday so I definitely object against any points for pole position. It also wouldn’t be good if the points system became too complicated and hard to understand for casual / new fans.

    Profile photo of Asanator

    Absolutely Not! There are too many points splashing about as it is!

    Profile photo of Fer no.65
    Fer no.65


    Someone getting the F1 title by setting a fastest lap/pole would be terrible (surely it happened in the 50’s, but now… it’d be horrible!)

    Profile photo of matt90

    I don’t see how winning a championship by finishing, say, 10th plus one point for fastest lap would be any worse than just finishing 9th.

    I agree that pole is wrong though, because pole is geared towards giving you the best chance in the race and could lead to a championship being won on a saturday, which isn’t right.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.