Vettel v Hamilton (42 posts)

  • Profile picture of US_Peter US_Peter said 2 years, 7 months ago:

    @nik I know what you mean, I’ve been frustrated by the limitations of how you can query the data on that site, but still it does seem to have the most data of any F1 site. It’s still not as complete an F1 site for fans as this is (thanks Keith)!

  • Profile picture of codesurge codesurge said 2 years, 7 months ago:

    @Icthyes

    “Hamilton has always trusted his team too much in costly situations; I don’t think Vettel has ever had that problem!”

    So true. Hamilton unquestioningly followed his team’s orders in Australia ’10 to his detriment (and subsequently griped about it over the radio), whereas Vettel soldiered on to a podium position with damaged brakes in Spain despite being told by his team to retire the car.

  • Profile picture of sunnyAK sunnyAK said 2 years ago:

    updated statistics:

    Vettel:
    Age 23
    Races 65
    Championships 1 (2010 youngest world champion ever)
    Wins 12
    Podiums 22
    Pole positions 18

    Hamilton:
    Age 26
    Races 74
    Championships 1 (2008)
    Wins 15
    Podiums 38
    Pole positions 18

    ———————————————————————————-

    i have updated the statistics, as they now differ from the first published statistics. vettel is now the youngest world champion ever has the same number of pole positions, but the better quote, because he needed less races for his 18 pole positions. hamilton was starting his career in the best car and had it for two years. (mclaren and ferrari were the best cars, being pretty equal in 2007 and 2008)

    vettel had the best car in 2010. this year it will be pretty close between mclaren and red-bull.

    vettel is the best qualifier at the moment, as he dominates webber for more than two years now and webber always was know as a (the) top qualifier.

    considering the drving qualities in the rain i see vettel ahead of hamilton and also when it comes to saving the tyres vettel has the advantage. (vettel showed great performances in the rain in the toro rosso. he won in this car)

    hamilton and vettel are equal in terms of race speed in dry conditions at the moment, but considering the age (as vettel is 23 years old and hamilton 26) vettel still has more potential, as with an age of only 23 years, he is farer away from his prime time than hamilton. with that said i am pretty sure that vettel will be the more complete and more successful driver.

    cheers
    sunnyAK

  • Profile picture of Calum Calum said 2 years ago:

    All depends on cars for stats.
    Give Button the class of the field, he will win the championship.
    Give Hamilton the class of the field, he will win the championship.
    Give Vettel the class of the field, he will win the championship.

    Takes some driver to win in anything but the class of the field, that is why Alonso gets credit, the RBR RB6 was stunning yet Alonso almost beat it!

    I do not think Vettel can prove he is better than Lewis this year because Lewis is handicapped by his Mclaren’s ability compared to the RB7 of Vettel. But Lewis will take huge plaudits if he can take the title this year in what is clearly not the class if the field!

    Just because Vettel is younger, I think he will win more titles than Lewis.

    3-2 to Vettel I think……. we’ll see in 10 years :P

  • Profile picture of driftin driftin said 2 years ago:

    This year, Hamilton has split the Red Bulls in the first two qualifying sessions, in a slower car, a tenth or so slower than Vettel. To me that suggests if he had a faster car such as the RB7 he’d be just as quick, if not quicker than the index-fingered German. On top of that, Hamilton has become famous for his aggression, his late braking and his overtaking abilities so usually when he doesn’t qualify well (which right now isn’t very often(, he makes up for that in the race.

    Vettel has a reputation for flying laps, but poor overtaking ability. We’re used to seeing him start at the front and stay there in the but when he gets mixed up in the midfield, can he really push past his title contenders? I think with experience he can, but with such a fast car being gifted to him will he get that experience? Hopefully the McLarens, Mercedes, Renaults and Ferraris can catch up with Red Bull in qualifying, not just to make the racing closer but to give the young German some experience of starting behind others.

    I believe that he’s a very good driver, just an inexperienced one who needs to learn how to race from the back more often in a worse car than he’s been used to to really sharpen his race skills. It’s nearing my bedtime so my memory’s a bit fuzzy and I can’t be bothered to look it all up now but I can’t really remember the last time Vettel had to fight his way through the midfield to get on the podium but I do clearly remember him clashing with Webber and smacking into Button last year.

    A GREAT driver can squeeze good results out of a mediocre car from the back or the middle of the grid, something which I reckon Hamilton showed us in 2009.

  • Profile picture of Dizzy-A Dizzy-A said 2 years ago:

    A GREAT driver can squeeze good results out of a mediocre car from the back or the middle of the grid, something which I reckon Hamilton showed us in 2009.

    That’s true, although Vettel did score regular points in 2008. I agree with the sentiment of your post though, Vettel is still relatively inexperienced but can hopefully get better at overtaking and such.

  • Profile picture of Pedal to the Vettel Pedal to the Vettel said 2 years ago:

    Er excuse me….vettel aged 23, Lewis aged 26, bit of an age gap don’t you think?

    Whatever Lewis did Vettel did it sooner, so why does vettel get labeled “can only win in a dominant Red Bull” where as Lewis failed to win in a dominant McLaren in 07 and nearly does it again in 08. Typical British media making out Lewis has the short end of the stick. I repeat a ROOKIE, almost wins the world title in a McLaren but yet vettel gets labeled “it’s all the car”, that’s just a sad, poor excuse from some of you lot, double standards.

    I think Abu Dhabi showed Lewis and Vettel at how equal they infact are. 3 hundreths of a second seperated them in quali and he still pulled away on race day.

    But OOOOOOOOOOOOO I’m sure you will all say that Lewis’ car was atleast 2 seconds off the pace and it was just all skill that made it that close, pfffffffffff.

    Cars seperate these 2 in speed not talent…

    (sarcasm) Oh yes lets bring up Vettel’s overtaking skills, right…….

    China 07/ 17th-4th

    Monaco 08/ 19th-5th
    Canada 08/ 19th-8th
    Belgium 08/10th-5th

    Belgium 09/8th-3rd
    Brazil 09/15th-4th

    Silverstone 10/24th-7th, after the first lap incident with Lewis.

    (sarcasm) Terribly sorry if there are no videos of him going up the grid, but the F1 media seemed to be more interested in Alonso and Lewis at the time.

    It’s also funny that Schumacher gets idolised for dragging up Ferrari from the pits of doom with the likes of Rory Byrne, Jean Todt and Ross Brawn helping him achieve all the records he has…

    So why is Adrian Newey, Vettel and Christian Horner any different from dragging a “nothing” team into the world championship spotlight.

    I just think certain F1 fans *cough* Macca fans *cough* are just jealous that they have a fight on their hands and have to keep comparing Lewis to vettel while the other side couldn’t care less.

  • Profile picture of Fixy Fixy said 2 years ago:

    I agree that Vettel and Hamilton (and I’d say Alonso too) are pretty equal in talent.

    Let’s list them by age:
    Alonso (29)
    Hamilton (26)
    Vettel (23)

    by debut season (experience):
    Alonso (2001)
    Hamilton (2007)
    Vettel (mid-2007)

    by titles:
    Alonso (x2 – 2005, 2006)
    Hamilton (x1 – 2008)
    Vettel (x1 – 2010)

    by possible titles when in a winning car:
    Alonso (2007, 2010)
    Hamilton (2007, 2010)
    Vettel (none)

    It’s easy to see how their success is proportional to their number of seasons and the cars they have driven. Hamilton has less experience than Alonso and thus is less successful in terms of statistics, but both have had winning cars and have won and lost with them.
    It is always difficult to try to compare drivers that have started racing in different years whilst they are still racing. Once all three will have retired it will be a lot easier to compare their statistics and make a sensible opinion. Up to then we must judge by what we have, and for now all three drivers have had the same chances and have used them at their benefit or not.
    We can’t say “Vettel is not mature, Alonso is” because their age and experience is different. And if Vettel has won so much without being an all-round driver, then we must fear what he will do when he will be more complete as a driver.

  • Profile picture of George George said 2 years ago:

    People seem to be forgetting Vettel had the fastest car for half of the 2009 season, I would add that to his ‘possible titles in a winning car’ list, it was certainly better compared to Hamilton’s car last year.

    Vettel seems to be fitting into the Schumacher zone very quickly to me, brilliant when he’s at the front and able to control the race, not so good at overtaking. If we still had refuelling I imagine we’d be seeing him putting him those crazy fast laps like Schumi used to do too.

  • Profile picture of Fixy Fixy said 2 years ago:

    I had that doubt, but half season is still too little to have title aspirations.

  • Profile picture of Dizzy-A Dizzy-A said 2 years ago:

    Vettel seems to be fitting into the Schumacher zone very quickly to me, brilliant when he’s at the front and able to control the race, not so good at overtaking.

    Schumacher is/was good at overtaking.

  • Profile picture of sunnyAK sunnyAK said 2 years ago:

    people often act like hamilton was the “king of overtaking”. the true king of overtaking was nigel mansell!
    http://sunnyak.forenworld.at/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=454
    talking about nowadays, vettel at the moment cannot prove his qualities concerning overtaking, as he in most cases is on the pole position and controls the race. however being on the pole position is not his fault. lol you cannot blame him for giving his best in the qualifying.
    however, talking about overtaking i donīt think hamilton is the best nowadays. what can he do that kobayashi canīt do? donīt get me wrong, hamilton showed good skills concerning overtaking and i respect him for these qualities, but kobayashi impressed me the most.
    for vettel we have to wait until he has a bad position and has to fight his way to the top…..

You need to log in to create and reply to topics. You can log in with your F1 Fanatic account here or sign up for an F1 Fanatic account here.

Advert | Go Ad-free