Who was the best driver of 2010? F1 Fanatic 2010 driver rankings (64 posts)

Topic tags: best driver of 2010, F1, F1 2010, Ferrari, formula 1, McLaren, Red Bull
  • Profile picture of Guilherme Guilherme said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    So here it goes, Guilherme’s rankings – part 1:

    27th – 17th

    27th – Sakon Yamamoto
    Would never have got anywhere near F1 if it wasn’t for his money, and shall stay away from an F1 car forever. Luckly he ran out of money and got replaced by Klien.

    26th – Karun Chandhok
    It is a pity that he didn’t get a chance to drive since Silverstone. He seems to be a reliable driver, but was outqualified by Senna too often. He’s the highest placed of the Hispania drivers but it has more to do with staying out of trouble than pure pace.

    25th – Bruno Senna
    He looked like a good driver when he was racing Chandok and Yamamoto. But then came Klien (who is average at best and hadn’t raced an F1 car since the 2006 Italian Grand Prix) and outqualifies him by 1.228 seconds! There are a lot of speculation linking him to Lotus, but I fear it has more to do with commercial opportunities rather than talent.

    24th – Lucas di Grassi
    Here’s one hard to rate. He was totally beaten by Glock, but then he was the clear number two and he has to deal with the weight problem. He has beaten Glock in qualifying only a couple of times and usually he falls behind in he race (or even before it!)

    23rd – Christian Klien
    Difficult to judge based only in three races. In Singapore he was great, only to retire with a hydraulics problem. He had the edge over Senna in Brazil and Singapore and kept him honest in Abu Dhabi, so I’d say it was a good comeback for him.

    22nd – Vitantonio Liuzzi
    You could hardly notice him for good reasons this year. To be fair, he had some acidents which wasn’t his fault, such as in Brazil, Japan and Abu Dhabi, but he just couldn’t beat Sutil. Less than half of this team mate points tells the story of 2010 for Liuzzi.

    21st – Pedro de la Rosa
    It was harsh the way he was sacked by Sauber, but Formula 1 has never been kind on anyone. He has an entire life of experience, yet was being beaten by his rookie team mate, and his replacement did a far better job.

    20th – Jarno Trulli
    I get the feeling that Jarno is not driving with his heart anymore. To end up at a dog of a car after years of nothing at Toyota damaged his motivation I think. Considering only his speed, I think he matched Kovalainen quite easily, but in Heikki you can see the motivation, the will to move forward. Jarno just seems to be racing towards retirement.

    19th – Sebastian Buemi
    I guess the greatest shame of this year was the car. It has started the season as the worst of the new teams and ended the season in same fashion. Buemi did what he could in his car, but his drive in Korea was just shameful and his defending moves at Brazil weren’t the cleanest ones I’ve ever seen. It seems like he hasn’t improved lately, and he desperately needs to, otherwise Alguersuari will take the Number 1 role sooner or later.

    18th – Vitaly Petrov
    I’m going to admit it, he is one of my favourite drivers. And that’s why I’m not going to forgive him for his mistakes this season. His drive at Hungaroring was what you would expect for a fairly experienced driver, so I got really excited by his “improvement”. But his mistake at Spa was just unforgiveable, and his crash at Korea was just not what he needed when he is fighting to prove he deserves a seat next year with Renault. He’s usually a good “come back” driver, but that wouldn’t be a problem if he managed to sort out his qualifying seasons. Also, he spent too much time in the lower midfield in a car capable of a points finish – Kubica’s 109 points advantage over him justify that. He seems to be one of the very best at defending though, and doesn’t seem to be bothered by pressure from other drivers – just look at his drives against Alonso in Turkey and Abu Dhabi.

    17th – Jaime Alguersuari
    I never liked this guy, to be really honest, but in my view he is one of the most improved drivers this season. He and Buemi are evenly matched, and he constantly dwells around 11th and 13th, picking up the odd point here and there. If he continues like this he might lead Toro Rosso next season.

  • Profile picture of Guilherme Guilherme said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    Why isn’t the new WDC higher up? Turkey, Spa and Hungary.

    I don’t want to stir up discussion here, as this is not the purpose of this thread, but Autosport is reporting that Vettel’s “mistake” at Hungary was in fact proposital, as he wanted to help Mark… would explain why he was so mad after the race…

  • Profile picture of Slr Slr said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    27. Christian Klein – Hard to judge on 3 races.
    26. Sakon Yamamoto – Well at least he finished most of his races.
    25. Bruno Senna – Pretty unspectaular.
    24. Vitaly Petrov – Was slaughtered by Kubica, should have at least been within range of Schumacher’s points.
    23. Karun Chandhok – The reason why HRT beat Virgin.
    22. Lucas di Grassi – Was OK, but didn’t really do anything.
    21. Pedro de la Rosa – Should have scored more points.
    20. Jamie Alguersuari – Would have been lower if he had not improved.
    19. Timo Glock – Better of the Virgin drivers.
    18. Sebastien Buemi – Decent driver, needs to find more pace.
    17. Vitantonio Liuzzi – Some great results, but they didn’t come often enough.
    16. Nick Heidfeld – Did well in the few races he did.
    15. Jarno Trulli – Finished well mostly.
    14. Heikki Kovalainen – Did what he had to do.
    13. Adrian Sutil – A season of two halves.
    12. Felipe Massa – Rarely competed with Alonso.
    11. Nico Hulkenberg – Big improvement after Hungary.
    10. Michael Schumacher – When he was good he was great, when he was bad, he was really bad.
    9. Rubens Barrichello – Strong consistant season.
    8. Kamui Kobayashi – Most entertaining driver of the year.
    7. Mark Webber – Did well mostly, but could deliver when it mattered the most.
    6. Jenson Button – Solid year.
    5. Lewis Hamilton – Also solid.
    4. Fernando Alonso – Great year overall, showed just how good he is.
    3. Sebatian Vettel – Deserved the championship.
    2. Robert Kubica – Consistant all year.
    1. Nico Rosberg – Highly underrated in my opinion, great results were overshadowed by Schumacher’s comeback.

  • Profile picture of Enigma Enigma said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    @Guilherme – Vettel was in 2nd behind Webber, so he decided to slow everyone down so that Webber would get an advantage and maybe get in 2nd. But doing that Vettel forgot about the 10 car lenghts rule, so it was his mistake.

    That’s how I see it anyway.

  • Profile picture of Guilherme Guilherme said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    @ Enigma: of course it was a mistake, but if what they say is true then it is not what everyone was thinking about at the time (that he wasn’t paying attention to the race or whatever)

  • Profile picture of Enigma Enigma said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    Yeah, you’re right.

  • Profile picture of Todfod Todfod said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    @M Sakr. WOW.. I think we agreed on the entire ranking from 27 to 4. We just completely disagreed on the top three. Check the 1st post.

  • Profile picture of sw6569 sw6569 said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    I won’t rank the drivers because Keith will be doing that. Instead, I give you my observations:

    Liuzzi – Last year I defended Liuzzi. His performances this year however cannot be excused. His incredible pre F1 record, like Hulkenberg’s just shows that F1 is a whole new ball game when it comes to talent.

    Hulkenberg – Two laps of note the whole season. Expected more.

    Kobayashi – Great to watch on television. Terrifying to be in front of. We know he’s got the speed and the balls to be in F1, but whether that will translate to him being a genuine front runner is difficult to know. Midfield passes are certainly easier than those at the front. Having said that, he’s the rookie of the year by some margin.

    Massa – Contractually bound to be Alonso’s number 2. Mentally Alonso’s number 2. A great shame that his career has come to this.

    Barrichello – A surprise of the season. Gutsy battles with Schumacher and some really good performances in a midfield car. He’s breaking longevity records for a reason.

    Rosberg – Not just a pretty face after all. Taken the fight to Schumacher and beaten him. Whether that continues into next season will be interesting to watch.

    Schumacher – Flashes of his old self. Flashes of his old teammates too. A season of highs and lows and little mediocrity. Assuming he is back next year after his monster crash with Liuzzi, his performances at the end of this year indicate he’s getting back to his best. One to watch.

    Alonso – He has his haters. He has his lovers. Neither can deny he outperforms every car he gets into though, any sportsmanship issues aside.

    Webber – His championship contender status rather over shadowed some rookie errors made in the early part of the season and a number of botched overtaking manoeuvres. Lost his head in Korea and never looked like the same driver from the mid season after that.

    Vettel – Deserving champion. Question-marks still surround his overtaking ability but given the amount of points he lost through reliability while leading, it seems fair that this year he was world champion. I hope to be proven wrong about his overtaking ability too.

    Button – Understated performance. Inspired first half of the season, good second half. If we have tyres next year that actually do degrade then expect him to be a real force.

    Timo Glock – Difficult to judge him on raw pace, but comfortably beat his teammate the whole season and occasionally tussled with the Lotus’. The star of the new teams in my opinion.

  • Profile picture of J_LH J_LH said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    For me Hamilton was the best –

    Single handedly made people believe in overtaking in F1 again at the beginning of the season.

    The only guy to successfully make 3 passes for the lead that wasn’t off the startline.

    Overtook many of his championship rivals as well as the mid field runners.

    Only had the 3rd fastest car yet managed to stay in the hunt right to the end despite terrible bad luck (Aus, Spain, Hungary, Singapore, Japan).

    Put his car in places that his world champion team-mate couldn’t even reach in his dreams.

    Only made one significant mistake (Monza).

    Bit tired at the moment but I’m sure I could think of more reasons.

  • Profile picture of Roberto Roberto said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    I can’t believe how many people are putting Hamilton as Number 1 and calling his driving mistakes ‘Dumb Luck’.

    The cold hearted truth is that if he didn’t make stupid ‘rookie’ errors that took him out of the race in Singapore and Italy he probably would’ve lifted the title.

    Fanboyism rules over common sense in this case.. hands down…

    Few drivers impressed me this Season.. Kubica and Rosberg most of all. I really hope they get a chance to have a go at the title in a faster car in the next few years. It would be a shame to let that talent go to waste.

    Top 10:

    1. Vettel (Same amount of Mistakes as Ham but actually lifted the title in the end. Needs to work on his composure and overtaking ability for next season)

    2. Alonso (Worst Car when compared to Red Bull and McLaren and still managed to fight for the title which he almost won)

    3. Hamilton (Almost got there in the end but the mistakes he made cost him dearly)

    4. Rosberg (Impressed a great deal and was held up only by Mercedes incompetence with the wheels and Webbers stupidity when he decided to roll back on the track in Korea)

    5. Kubica (Strong as always in an inferior car, needs a fast car badly)

    6. Webber (Some good results, but he just doesn’t have what it takes to be World Champion it seems. Threw it all away when it mattered.)

    7. Button (Strong start to the season, but just let himself go after that. No idea why.)

    8. Schumacher (Flashes of his old self (Eg. when he defended his position against Button…Overtake of Alo in Monaco) but want to see more of it)

    9. Sutil/Barichello (Can’t choose as both made the most of the Williams/Force India Cars they were given and beat their team mates comfortably. Ended up with same points in championship as well)

    10. Massa (Didn’t get a feeling he really wanted the title at any time during the season)

  • Profile picture of TrueF1Grit TrueF1Grit said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    I don’t see why everyone is ranking Alguresuari so low.
    He had a string of 11 place finishes, and a few in the points. He may not have a huge amount of points but they were earned with some good drivers.
    “Lost a lot of point scoring positions”
    But at least he was in these positions! Unlike other driver, for example his team mate.

  • Profile picture of Icthyes Icthyes said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    Roberto, if you’re going to adopt a superiority complex and call people derogatory terms, at least be consistent. If winning with the third best car is so important, why have you ranked Button – the only guy to actually win in what was the the third best car at that track – ranked so low?

    TrueF1Grit I agree, Jaime has done quite well this season and has shown more potential than the more experienced Buemi.

  • Profile picture of Todfod Todfod said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    @ Ichtyes. Button is ranked low because his victories were flukes.. and he hasn’t had the pace to take a pole position all season.. Monza was close.. but not god enough.

  • Profile picture of daykind daykind said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    27 – Sakon Yamamoto. Didn’t bring anything to a team already in trouble. Not bad in Spa or Hockenheim, but got his seat because of his money.

    26 – Jarno Trulli. After strong efforts last year, couldn’t do anything against Heikki. Was only best of new teams a few times when I expected him to thrash Kovalainen.

    25 – Bruno Senna. Biggest name but smallest results. Looked to be a decent driver but Klien and Chandhok seem to have more skill.

    24 – Tonio Liuzzi. Thrashed by his team mate. Showed initial promise after a point at Bahrain, but fell apart from then on. Did well in Korea, and in Silverstone, where he held on despite Alonso behind him for a while.

    23 – Pedro de La Rosa. Disappointing comeback but good drives at Valencia and Hungary. A good driver but won’t get another opportunity at a big team.

    22 – Lucas Di Grassi. I quite simply expected more from him. As someone who was once a test driver for the Renault team, I thought he would have picked up tips from the guys there, including Alonso. However, he’s just been destroyed by Glock all season.

    21 – Nick Heidfeld. Two points finishes in just five races was quite good. Unlucky Singapore but comfortably justified Sauber’s decision to biring him in in place of De La Rosa.

    20 – Christian Klien. He comfortably defeated Senna in Singapore and Abu Dhabi, and looked all round better than the other three HRT’s.

    19 – Karun Chandhok. A solid first ten races in a rotten car. Seems extremely knowledgeable about the sport and the situation at HRT. A nice guy who deserves another chance.

    18 – Nico Hulkenberg. I expected so much of him, and yet he only delivered once, with his pole in Brazil. Overall was comprehensively beaten by Rubens. I seem to be the only one who thinks Williams made the right decision today.

    17 – Vitaly Petrov. Constantly crashing but a good performance in Hungary, Belgium and dare I say it, Abu Dhabi? I’ve been impressed with pieces of his driving, including setting fastest lap at China.

    16 – Sebastien Buemi. Extremely strong performance at Canada, but very average elsewhere. Particularly when Jaime got three consecutive 11th’s and he was crashing into Glock at Korea.

    15 – Timo Glock. Wrestled his dire Virgin to some good results. Obviously he’s good enough for a Force India seat, Renault seat or Williams seat, but seems fairly happy at Virgin. Out qualified his team mate by the highest margin on the grid, 18-1.

    14 – Heikki Kovalainen. Top of the new teams and got a 12th and two 13th’s. Usually been strong in qualifying and twice made it through to Q2. Just disappointing when higher up the gird, making poor start in Belgium. He seems to care more about Lotus and it’s long hard slog than Jarno.

    13 – Adrian Sutil. I had him in 6th place in my half term rankings but has been very poor since then. I did rate him as a top class driver, but after his erratic performance at Yeongam, my opinion has changed. Sorry Sutil-M!

    12 – Jaime Alguersuari. I thought he would be really poor, but in my opinon he totally crushed Buemi, and drove well in the last four races of the season. I think he’s one to watch for the future.

    11 – Rubens Barrichello. After his amazing year last year, few expected him to challenge for the title again. However, I thik that he has been an interesting driver this year, and after some excellent performances at Valencia, Silverstone and Hungary, he’s been good this year. He’s not in the top ten after his mistakes in Monaco and Spa.

    10 – Michael Schumacher. Probably the most eagerly-anticipated driver of 2010, and while his comeback overall has being poor, he’s being driving a Mercedes that isn’t a patch on last year’s Brawn, which is always hard. Strong performances at Bahrain, Spain, Monaco, Turkey, Japan, Korea and Brazil cemented his place as asn all time great, and in my eyes he will be champion next year.

    9 – Kamui Kobayashi. A great driver who showed his promise after Brazil and Abu Dhabi last year and lived up to it this year, with a superb pass on Alonso in Valencia, and completely lightened up the race at Suzuka, with some powerful overtakes, all at the same hairpin!

    8 – Nico Rosberg. Ok, he’s beaten the greatest of them all this season, and he’s got three podiums, but I think he’s being over rated. I know he drove very well at China, leading a lot of the race, but I don’t think he was exceptional in Malaysia or Silverstone, but he was good in Bahrain and Abu Dhabi. Would have got 2nd in Korea but for Webber’s error. I can’t help but feel that he’ll get murdered by Schumi next year though.

    7 – Felipe Massa. “Fernando is faster than you.” That was the infamous Hockenheim message depriving Massa of a possible victory, but it’s also the story of Felipe’s season. Alonso has being faster than him, much faster. Massa got a great result in Bahrain, but Alonso passed him on Lap One. Good in Italy, Germany, Singapore, Spa, Korea and Hungary, but I expect a championship fight from the Brazilian next season, otherwise the man who’s up next will have his seat.

    6 – Robert Kubica. As you probably guessed from my verdict on Massa, Robert’s next. This year for me he’s proved his class. He’s being out of the points only four times, the same as the World Champion. He’s only being out of Q3 once, and that was in the very last race. He out-qualified his team mate 17-2 also. A driver of the highest caliber.

    5 – Lewis Hamilton. The first of the five title contender’s to appear. He managed to beat the defending world champion, which is hard enough without him as your team mate. A great drive in Turkey, as well as a electrifying battle with Alonso and Button in Canada were a great way to really kick-start his campaign. Before that race he was only 8th in the championship. A masterful drive in Belgium was followed by two schoolboy errors in Italy and Singapore helped write off his title hopes. Korea and Abu Dhabi were high points though.

    4 – Jenson Button. Two early wins gave him the lead in the championship, but he didn’t win since then. Good calls in Melbourne and China gave him two memorable wins, which weren’t followed up until being a part in two consecutive one-two’s in Turkey and Canada. He had dreadful luck in Belgium, but called it right in Monza to take a well-deserved 2nd place. Good drive in Abu Dhabi capped off a strong debut season for the men in silver.

    3 – Mark Webber. He probably will never get a better shot at the title than this year. He won 4 races, with an outstanding performance in Monaco. Horrible luck in Turkey with Vettel’s error, and drove stellar races until Korea, where he threw away his title. Sliding over the kerb and hitting the barrier has to be the lowest point of his career. Beaten and beaten well by Vettel in qualifying, and also in a lot of the race. I would have liked him to win the title, but I fear he will become another of F1’s nearly men.

    2 – Fernando Alonso. It pains me to put him second, but that’s where he finished. He was incredible this year, with great drives in Bahrain, Monaco, Hungary, Italy, Singapore and Korea helping him to secure his status as one of the best. I was in a minority of one when after the British GP I tipped him to become champion, but he wasn’t far off. Some big mistakes cost him the championship though.

    1 – Sebastian Vettel. It pains me even more to put him ahead of Alonso, as for me they have been neck and neck all season. Vettel has had some appalling luck with engines, spark plugs but has also made a lot of mistakes, but so has Alonso and Hamilton, and they still contended for the championship. I think that Turkey, Hungary and Belgium hurt him badly, but his five wins were nothing but excellent. He took ten poles, including superb laps in Bahrain, Germany and Abu Dhabi. A deserved champion.

  • Profile picture of Keith Collantine Keith Collantine said 2 years, 6 months ago:

    Reading your comments so far it occurs to me that one of the trickiest things about this how to view mistakes.

    For example was Alonso’s error at Shanghai worse than Vettel’s at Spa – or are they the same thing? Does Hamilton deserve some, none or all the blame for failing to finish at Singapore?

You need to log in to create and reply to topics. You can log in with your F1 Fanatic account here or sign up for an F1 Fanatic account here.

Advert | Go Ad-free