Group Admins

  • Profile picture of Keith Collantine

Group Mods

  • Profile picture of damonsmedley
  • Profile picture of Bradley Downton

F1

Public Group active 46 minutes ago

F1 discussion

Worst crash at each track

This topic contains 13 replies, has 13 voices, and was last updated by Avatar of SouthAussie94 SouthAussie94 3 years, 5 months ago.

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #128289
    Avatar of Polishboy808
    Polishboy808
    Participant

    We’ve seen some big crashes this season, but what were the worst crashes for wach track. We can also use historic race tracks. And although a driver dies at that track, its not neccesarily the worst accident there.

    Albert Park: 2010 Kobayashi

    Circuit Gilles Villenveuve: 2007 Kubica

    Valencia Street Circuit: 2010 Webber

    Circuit de Spa Francorchamps: 1998 just about everyone

    Suzuka: 2009 Alguersuari (I cant remember any other ones)

    Yeongam: 2010 Petrov

    Interlagos: 2003 Just about everyone

    Imola: 1989 Gerhard Berger

    #149123
    Avatar of Mark Hitchcock
    Mark Hitchcock
    Participant

    The one for Suzuka that springs to mind for me is Mcnish’s one in Quali in ’02: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DFJmJsV_PMk

    #149124
    Avatar of Icthyes
    Icthyes
    Participant

    Brundle at Albert Park, surely? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItC4s1WDAbU

    #149125
    Avatar of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    Didn’t MSC also have a big shunt at 139R in 1991? If anyone can find a YouTube link…please share.

    #149126
    Avatar of Bleu
    Bleu
    Participant

    Current ones, and only including F1 what I have seen since I started following:

    Sakhir – not very bad ones there, but I say Hamilton in FP some years ago.

    Melbourne – Brundle 1996

    Sepang – Herbert 2000

    Shanghai – Karthikeyan 2005

    Barcelona – Kovalainen 2008

    Istanbul – nothing big there either, but I choose 2008 start incident where Fisichella flew through the air

    Montreal – Kubica 2007

    Valencia – Webber 2010

    Silverstone – Schumacher 1999

    Hockenheim (new) – start crash 2003

    Hungaroring – well Massa’s one was just freak incident and the crash into tyre wall wasn’t the worst one. I say Firman 2003

    Spa – Zanardi 1993

    Monza – 1st lap crash 2000

    Singapore – Piquet 2008

    Suzuka – McNish 2002

    Yeongam – Petrov 2010

    Interlagos – Alonso 2003

    Abu Dhabi – none

    #149127
    Avatar of
    Anonymous

    I think the worst at China was Buemi’s. There isn’t much scarier than going down that huge straight and just as you go to brake your wheels fly off!

    Agree with the rest of your list though Bleu although Christian Fittipaldi’s Monza backflip was probably the most spectacular crash at that track but not the worst.

    #149128
    Avatar of Dan Thorn
    Dan Thorn
    Participant

    What about Monaco? There’s a whole host of choices for that. Fisi’s in 2005 was quite big, and Brundle’s in 1984 was bad as well. Then there’s the huge start line pile up caused by Derek Daly in 1980, and Jenson’s massive shunt in practice in 2003 which meant he couldnt start the race.

    There was also a colossal shunt in the 1950 race when a freak wave soaked the track and caused a massive pile up, and who can forget when Ascari plunged into the harbour in ’55.

    And though it wasn’t particularly destructive, but when Brabham crashed out of the lead on the last corner of the last lap in 1970 it must have been pretty bad for him!

    #149129
    Avatar of James_mc
    James_mc
    Participant

    Regarding Bahrain, I would say Kimi’s suspension failure in 2006

    #149130
    Avatar of damonsmedley
    damonsmedley
    Participant

    Disagree with Melbourne. Villeneuve’s crash in 2001 was definitely the worst, regardless of the fatality! He hadn’t hit the brakes, so he was doing about 180mph when he connected with Ralf’s Williams, he flew through the air, made heavy contact with the barriers mid-flight before cart-wheeling through the gravel trap. I am struggling to think of a more scary accident in the history of Formula 1! And I think Senna’s fatal or Piquet’s 1987 crashes at Tamburello were worse than Berger’s. Berger didn’t actually hit the wall as hard, he was just unlucky that the impact ruptured the fuel cell.

    I agree with most others though. McNish’s crash at Suzuka in 2002 remains the only time I have seen a car go through the barrier! Firman’s crash in Hungary 2003 was also horrendous.

    #149131
    Avatar of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    A few more to consider from the current tracks:

    Interlagos – Brundle, Irvine Verstapppen 94. Not massive, but pretty scary bearing in mind the fact that Verstappen’s wheel actually hit Brundle on the noggin.

    Montreal – Panis 97. Ruined what could have been his best F1 season.

    Monaco – Wendelinger 94. He was in a coma for months after this crash.

    #149132
    Avatar of Ads21
    Ads21
    Participant
    #149133
    Avatar of nik
    nik
    Member

    On the flip-side, how about ‘worst’ crash in terms of ‘oh my god I can’t believe he just did that’

    China – Hamilton ’07

    Japan – Vettel into Webber ’08

    #149134
    Avatar of Journeyer
    Journeyer
    Participant

    Sakhir – Hamilton 2008 (FP) or Raikkonen 2006 (quali)

    Melbourne – Ralf/JV 2001

    Sepang – Herbert 2000 or Ralf/Webber 2005

    Shanghai – Karthikeyan 2005

    Barcelona – Kovalainen 2008

    Monaco – Wendlinger 1994 (quali)

    Istanbul – Montoya 2005 (although that’s rather tame)

    Montreal – Paletti 1982

    Valencia – Webber 2010

    Silverstone – Scheckter 1973

    Hockenheim (new) – start crash 2003

    Hungaroring – Firman 2003

    Spa – 1st lap 1998 (by miles)

    Monza – von Trips 1961, Rindt 1970, Petersen 1978

    Singapore – Piquet 2008

    Suzuka – Senna/Prost 1990

    Yeongam – Petrov 2010

    Interlagos – Alonso 2003

    Abu Dhabi – none

    #149135
    Avatar of SouthAussie94
    SouthAussie94
    Participant

    Its not F1 but the worst crash at Abu Dhabi would probably have to be Natacha Gachnang’s crash where she went straight on at the end of the straight.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRwtsjh91fQ

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.