GeeMac

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 1,039 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #316951
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    I watched the race on Channel 4 after having watched Melbourne on Sky (thanks to my sister in law giving me her SkyGo login details) and I have to say I liked it, though I do miss hearing Brundle’s opinion I must admit.

    I’m still up in the air about Steve Jones, he isn’t bad but he clearly doesn’t have the depth of knowledge that is necessary to lead the broadcast but he is doing a professional job. DC and Webber are a nice duo, makes me wonder how much fun engineering meetings at Red Bull must have been in 07/08. Ben Edwards was his usual solid self and Karun Chandhok was underused in the race I feel. While he probably doesn’t have the gravitas of DC or Webber because his F1 career never really took off, he knows his onions and always talks sense. I’m not sure why Susie Wolff got so much airtime, she doesn’t add much to the broadcast and she was barely audible, I’m glad Toto highlighted the point! Also, why give her the RBR steering wheel to explain the start procedures when you have the WEC champion and a veteran of 7 seasons with Red Bull standing right next to her?

    So it was a good start for C4, lots to build on.

    #315951
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    deliberately relying on TDI – the world’s most successful automotive efficiency technology – at Le Mans

    I see what you did there VAG…

    #315887
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    The system would have actually been worth looking into had the drivers been able to do more than one quick lap on a set of tyres. Since they can’t it was completely nonsensical, the teams can only turn cars around so quickly.

    #314796
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    That’s not a bad team, as I will most likely be watching Channel 4 this year I’m pleased with what they put together.

    I like DC as a commentator, not sure how I feel about Ben Edwards. I was a fan but he did miss a bit last season. I really like that Karun Chandhok is involved, he did some TV work with BeIn Sports in the Middle East and he was always well informed, knowledgeable and passionate. Getting Murray Walker and Prost involved is a bit of a coup, wonder what they’ll be doing.

    #313506
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    It has be stay. As everyone else has said, you run a driver of the weekend poll which distinguishes it from FOM’s poll and we generally all put a lot more thought into it that the people who will be voting on social media during/following a race.

    And as others have said, if it turns into a popularity contest with the likes of Raikkonen or Haryanto winning consistently regardless of their performance FOM will probably drop it.

    #312437
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    1. Mercedes – They won’t be challenged until 2017 at the earliest.
    2. Ferrari – They’ll get closer, but not close enough.
    3. Williams – Stuck in no mans land again, hopefully they’ll be able to get more podiums this season.
    4. Force India – They’ll continue the upward trend…mostly because of the Mercedes lump in the back and the quality of their drivers.
    5. Red Bull – No number of Tag Heuer badges will hide the PU’s shortcomings.
    6. Toro Rosso – I don’t see them getting much higher with a year old PU.
    7. Renault – Rebuilding year, they’ll be grabbing the odd points finish.
    8. McLaren – Over the course of the season they should outscore Manor, Haas and Sauber. If they don’t they should seriously question where their cash is going.
    9. Manor – A reliable, up to date Mercedes PU should see them grab some early season points.
    10. Haas – I think they’ll be quicker than Manor over the course of the year, but there will be early season teething problems that will limit their points scoring opportunities.
    11. Sauber – They have seriously lost their way and need someone to take over the team and give them some direction.

    #312061
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    Really surprised that Chilton managed to land a seat at a team as good as Ganassi to be honest. I had assumed that they would be funded well enough not to need a driver with a budget (which Max is surely bringing). He hasn’t really set the world alight in any of the series he has raced in, so he has really managed to land on his feet and it’ll be interesting to see how he performs. If he can’t succeed in Indycar with Ganassi, he won’t succeed with anyone.

    #312013
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    “Was Maldonado poised for a breakthrough?” Without him putting his hands up, admitting that he is at fault for the vast majority (granted not all) of the incidents he has been involved in over the course of his career, no.

    Having Maldonado and Grosjean in the same team was a great marker for the development of the two drivers. Both are GP2 champions, both have massive raw pace, both are seemingly nice family guys out the car and both have(had) a reputation for being a bit wayward. But only Grosjean put his hands up, sought help and managed to overcome his reputation as a crasher (or first lap nutcase if you prefer). Maldonado has the capacity to do the same, but because he seems to steadfastly deny hat he has any failings he will never fulfil his potential.

    Maldonado may end up regretting not asking for Grosjean’s psychologist’s phone number.

    #311382
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    I think we all agree that tarmac runoff is evil. Other than that, I’m pretty sure we disagree on practically everything else which is no bad thing as it promotes healthy debate among fans.

    #311315
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    He is the real deal for me, a massive talent. He’s quick, level headed and he seems to be dedicated and personable. In the right equipment he will win races and championships.

    #311206
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    I think people will assume, as this is a sideways step to an extent, that he will walk it, but I am not so sure it will be that easy. There is a lot of talent at the sharp end of the Super Formula grid and he will be racing on a few tracks he has never seen before. His reputation is on the line here, if he doesn’t do well it’ll be seen as a major failure as Super Formula isn’t really regarded as a frontline series by many (wrongly of course). If he does win it people will say “well, with his pedigree, he should have shouldn’t he”. It’s sort of a lose lose situation for him.

    As good as Vandoorne is he is going to have to have his wits about him next season, this isn’t going to just be a victory lap before slipping into a McLaren race seat in 2017.

    #311061
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    Honestly, the blog is pretty much spot on at the moment. The round-up and regular (and it must be said, speedy) news updates keep us up to date with what is happening while the regular comment pieces and “rate the race”/”driver of the weekend” sections create room for debate. I have to mention that I love the “start shots” piece you do ahead of each race, it really whets the appetite ahead of a Grand Prix. The post-race statistics is also another piece I always really look forward to, the comments never fail to turn up a few gems.

    I do miss are the technical pieces you used to put up periodically however (in collaboration with a chap whose name has slipped my mind) and, speaking selfishly as someone who no longer uses social media, I do miss the weekend in tweets summary you used to do. Lots of tweets over the weekend are either just bumf or poor “jokes” from teams PR people, but you always managed to pick out the key ones and it added colour to the coverage of the weekend. The odd Top 10 wouldn’t go amiss either, there have been some crackers over the years.

    Keep up the good work @keithcollantine!

    #310436
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    Well the rule as I always understood it was “all the time you have to leave a space”…

    #310428
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    @magon4 “Can’t understand how HUL is that far behind PER – gotta take into account the whole season!” Yup, these ratings are always skewed, drivers who do better in the latter half of the season always end yup higher in the rankings.

    Anyway, here is my 2p’s worth.

    21. Mehri – Shaded by Stevens, competent but probably shouldn’t be in F1.
    20. Rossi – Performed well against the only person you could fairly compare him to. If performance was all that mattered that seat should have been his all season.
    19. Maldonado – I really do want Pastor to succeed, and I do think he is genuinely quick enough to be in F1, but his failure to learn from his mistakes means that if I was running a team I wouldn’t give him a seat.
    18. Stevens – Competent, but struggled to beat both Mehri and Rossi.
    17. Raikkonen – Utterly dominated by Vettel, when he did stand on the podium it had more to do with the inherent pace of the ST15-T than his driving. If poor Jules had been around you would be heading to retirement.
    16. Ericsson – Did well against Nasr, but…
    15. Nasr – he got the headline grabbing result. And it was his rookie year.
    13. Alonso – Hard to judge these two given how poor the MP4-30 was, so I’ll rank them the same somewhere in the midfield
    13. Button – Ditto.
    12. Massa – Comparisons to Bottas’ points total ignore the fact that Bottas didn’t race in Melbourne. Wasn’t really at his best this season, but he did have his moments.
    11. Ricciardo – Disappointing year for me, he deserved a much better car than he got. He’s still a star of the field though but I ranked Kvyat higher because (a) he scored more points over the season and (b) got the team’s best result.
    10. Kvyat – A coming of age season, started wobbly (though that was probably down to the car) but he really did come on strong. Still made a few errors but he is young. A star of the future and deserving of his seat.
    9. Sainz – I’m sympathetic to Sainz because he will inevitably get less plaudits than Verstappen because the latter is a teenager. But let’s not forget that Sainz is only 20 and he got by far the worse of the reliably gremlins (one of which hit when Verstappen scored very heavily).
    8. Verstappen – Was terrific, but let’s not forget that some of his season highlights (like the lauded “pass round the outside of Blanchimont” were down to tyre advantages – and at Blanchimont track limits violations). He is a phenomenal talent but lets see how he does in season 2.
    7. Grosjean – The Lotus was an ok car but the team lacked the cash to develop it. That never got him down and he consistently out-performed it and his team mate. Spa was one of the drives of the season.
    6. Rosberg – Feel like I’m being generous by ranking him so high up. While the championship was still up for grabs he was 10-3 down in race wins and 12-4 behind in qualifying. He did perform well at the end of the season, but the damage was already done.
    5. Hulkenberg – Started stronger than Perez, performed really well all season (other than a late season wobble). And he won Le Mans for goodness sake.
    4. Perez – Probably his best season, was as good as Hulkenberg but edges it because he (again) got the headline grabbing results.
    3. Bottas – I know a lot of people will disagree with this, but he was the best non-Mercedes/Ferrari driver most weekends and he was in with a shout of beating one of them in the championship despite starting one less race. Took his opportunities and made few mistakes. Consolidated his position as one of the top talents of the future.
    2. Hamilton – It’s hard not to rank the man who dominated in the way Hamilton did number one, but the performance advantage the W06 had meant that probably any top driver would have won the championship in it. If Hamilton had carried on winning after the championship was sealed he would have been number 1.
    1. Vettel – A massive transformation from Vettel. He was by far the most impressive driver of the year and he was sublime in the races he did win and he kept the Mercedes honest all year when the SF15-T didn’t have the pace to win. Utterly obliterated Raikkonen. And he was the star of the post-race press conference.

    #309487
    Profile photo of GeeMac
    GeeMac
    Participant

    If Ticktum was willing to do something that stupid over an incident that minor he thoroughly deserves that ban.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 1,039 total)