My F1 driver rankings based on race weekend grades (2013)
- This topic has 35 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 5 months ago by magon4.
- AuthorPosts
- 24th March 2013, 19:42 at 7:42 pm #132927magon4Participant
I have an excel going on every year and I’ll share my ranking after every race. If you do the same, share it here, too!
After 2 races:1. Sebastian Vettel 8,5
2. Jules Bianchi 8,5
3. Adrian Sutil 8,3
4. Nico Rosberg 8,0
5. Jenson Button 7,8
6. Felipe Massa 7,8
7. Lewis Hamilton 7,8
8. Nico Hülkenberg 7,5
9. Paul Di Resta 7,5
10. Kimi Raikkonen 7,3
11. Jean-Eric Vergne 7,3
12. Mark Webber 6,8
13. Fernando Alonso 6,5
14. Valtteri Bottas 6,3
15. Charles Pic 6,3
16. Daniel Ricciardo 6,0
17. Guido van der Garde 6,0
18. Romain Grosjean 5,5
19. Sergio Perez 5,0
20. Max Chilton 4,5
21. Esteban Gutierrez 4,3
22. Pastor Maldonado 4,024th March 2013, 19:48 at 7:48 pm #229410Bradley DowntonParticipantHow are Perez and Button so far apart when they’ve done a fairly equal job?
and how is Chilton behind van der Garde?What is this based on? Your personal opinion?
24th March 2013, 19:52 at 7:52 pm #229411the_sigmanParticipantΙ will definitely make one! Interesting!
24th March 2013, 20:48 at 8:48 pm #229412magon4ParticipantIt’s based on my personal opinion of what I have observed.
Button has been far superior, mostly today, where he dealt with the weather much better and would’ve been able to keep Massa behind him; Perez couldn’t even deal with the Lotus!
Chilton looks worse than Van der Garde, mostly because of the team mate comparison. He should be able to finish races and qualies in front of the dutch, which he mostly doesn’t.24th March 2013, 21:11 at 9:11 pm #229414SlrParticipantGuido van der Garde
You may want to spell Van der Garde’s first name correctly before you offend any Italian-Americans on this website. :)
24th March 2013, 21:14 at 9:14 pm #229415KingsharkParticipantVery harsh on Perez.
Also, how come Alonso and Raikkonen are so low? What did they both get in Malaysia? I’m presuming Alonso no more than a 5, although he did overtake Webber twice with a broken front wing, Gilles Villeneuve style!
25th March 2013, 3:41 at 3:41 am #229416wsrgoParticipantSuch rankings are all rubbish. They’re based on nothing more than personal opinion,even though those who compile them punch in a vast bunch of useless numbers on a God knows what basis for credibility.
14th April 2013, 9:39 at 9:39 am #229417magon4Participant@wsrgo then do the decent thing and don’t come into this thread!
after china:
1. VET 8,3
2. BIA 8,2
3. BUT 8,0
4. RAI 7,8
5. HUL 7,8
6. HAM 7,8
7. SUT 7,7
8. ALO 7,5
9. DIR 7,5
10. VER 7,3
11. RIC 7,2
12. ROS 7,0
13. MAS 7,0
14. PIC 6,5
15. WEB 6,3
16. BOT 6,3
17. GRO 5,7
18. VDG 5,2
19. PER 5,2
20. MAL 4,7
21. CHI 4,3
22. GUT 4,014th April 2013, 9:42 at 9:42 am #229418magon4Participant@Kingshark He lost to Massa on Saturday, made a mistake against Vettel and then a second mistake of not pitting. Gave him a 4.5
@slr who mispelled Guido?14th April 2013, 9:53 at 9:53 am #229419KingsharkParticipant@magon4
Did you see his one race lap though? It was amazing! In the rain, with his front wing hanging off, Fernando overtook Webber twice around the outside! That was the closest thing to Gilles Villeneuve driving we’ve seen in the past 30 years or so.Sarcasm aside, I agree that he should’ve gotten a low score, but mind you I need to point out that the strategic decision to keep Alonso out with a dangling front wing was not his fault.
14th April 2013, 10:13 at 10:13 am #229420magon4ParticipantI agree with you and thought that was incredible too. Alonso is probably the best driver out there. But I do think he knew how bad it looked; he did trust his team on it, though.
14th April 2013, 10:23 at 10:23 am #22942114th April 2013, 10:43 at 10:43 am #229422magon4Participantups thanks for correcing that!
13th May 2013, 18:00 at 6:00 pm #229423magon4ParticipantHere goes, after Barcelona. I modified my formula a little to include an evaluation of the standard deviation. Constant high grades get you extra points, constant low ones extra minus. With current form (average of last 3 races), top performances (best 3 races) and total average carrying 74% (6% for current form, 12% for stellar performances and 8% for consistency), here is the ranking.
1. VET
2. ALO
3. RAI4. DIR
5. BUT
6. HAM
7. BIA
8. HUL
9. SUT10. RIC
11. ROS
12. MAS13. PIC
14. VER
15. PER
16. GRO
17. BOT18. WEB
19. MAL
20. VDG21. GUT
22. CHI
13th May 2013, 18:05 at 6:05 pm #229424KingsharkParticipantButton ahead of Hamilton? Sutil ahead of Rosberg? I have to disagree.
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.