Traction control ban: Better races, less safe, more controversy?

Karun Chandhok, Red Bull-Renault, Barcelona, 2008 testing, 2007 | GEPA / Franz PammerIt’s been interesting to see how the drivers and teams reacted to last week’s test at which most (if not all) the teams tried running the cars with the standard electronic control unit for 2008 installed and the removal of traction control.

Questions have been raised over safety and how hard it will be to implement the ban. But many drivers have also said the cars are now more fun to drive and the racing will be better.

Negative

Some drivers have suggested the development will make racing less safe, and other voiced the fear that it’s a technological backward step.

The fact is I didn’t have any experience without traction control and I was rubbish. It’s interesting. The throttle used to be like a button, you’d lift or floor it with no half measures. Now you need to be as smooth as possible. The laptimes have been good immediately, that’s a sign that we’ve started on the right footing.

But from a safety point of view, these limitations in the use of electronics look like a step backwards to me: in the event of wet races we’ll have a lot more accidents.

Felipe Massa

Without traction control it is much more difficult to accelerate – you have to apply your foot on the throttle much more carefully.

It is more fun to drive but also more difficult. We are going to see more mistakes because it is easier to lose control when you are pushing, but there will be the same winners.

Personally I prefer cars with full electronics. In terms of technology and safety, I think it is a backwards step.

Pedro de la Rosa

We ran into major problems at the start of the programme. We had a lot of discussions with the McLaren Electronics Engineers to overcome them and most have been solved. But it’s been a difficult birth.

Bob Bell, Renault

Positive

Michael Schumacher, Ferrari, Barcelona, 2008 testing, 2007 | Ferrari MediaOthers said they felt driving the car was now more fun and that it would make the racing better.

I was very happy to back driving today. I have to say that driving without any assistance, as was the case today is really great.

You have to pay attention to your driving, your reaccelerating, your tyre wear and behind the wheel it’s fun.

Heikki Kovalainen

It was more difficult than I expected and it gets especially difficult when the tyres go off. When they’re new it’s how I imagined but when they go off it gets really difficult – more on the traction side than on the braking side. I guess that’s because everything on the car has been developed in harmony with traction control.

It will probably make a difference to the racing. There will be more mistakes, more overtaking and more sliding around; it’s more fun.

Nick Heidfeld

It will be really interesting to watch the races next year as there is no traction control. It’s not only more interesting for the drivers, but also for the fans.

The races can only get more spectacular now, but if it can really give a bit of an advantage to a team has yet to be seen. I expect that the same top teams will still be out there winning races.

Michael Schumacher

The F1 cars had become too easy: if a new guy came in and did some good laptimes, a star was born. Now, by contrast, they are harder, so more enjoyable: you need sensitivity and capability in managing the throttle.

Of course, by the end of winter we’ll lap on the same times as this year, but we’ll see the difference between who is truly good and the rest.

Luca Badoer

Technical changes

Here’s some quotes on how it will change team’s approaches to setting up the cars and designing them in the first place.

One technician even suggested that there might be disputes if some teams are suspected to have found a way around it.

The places where you’ll miss traction control the most is at the exit of first- and second-gear corners. But as soon as the car gathers downforce, then it’s no longer a problem.

Anthony Davidson

It will be harder to get on the throttle on the exit of the corners so the aero might become more important. Maybe even the drag levels will change as teams run more wing to make sure the driver can get on the throttle early.

Suspension geometry will also change. There are a lot of little things like that we’ll discover over winter testing.

Sam Michael, Williams

From the engine point of view, mapping will be essential. The way you tune the mapping in real time after a session will be important.

There will be a certain number of positions [on the steering wheel dial] and it wil be up to us and the driver to anticipate what to put in those maps.

Gilles Simon, Ferrari

It’s a reasonably good system and will be tough to get round. But if you’ve got 20 electronics engineers with time on their hands to look at it, then there will always be possibilities to exploit the rules.

Mike Gascoyne, Force India F1 Team

Photos: GEPA / Franz Pammer | Ferrari Media

Read more about traction control

Advert | Go Ad-free

16 comments on Traction control ban: Better races, less safe, more controversy?

  1. Journeyer said on 22nd November 2007, 9:15

    Mike Gascoyne is right on the money. There will definitely be workarounds for this. It’s a question of how the other teams will react to it… will we have another major scandal? Hopefully not.

    Just a warning: the last time F1 removed traction control was in 1994. It did have safety ramifications, as we all sadly know. However, unlike then, this TC ban was announced as early as the end of last year, so teams have had much more time making sure there are no major safety issue. Nonetheless, expect more dangerous accidents this year than in years past.

  2. nellyweb said on 22nd November 2007, 9:43

    Removing traction control had nothing to do with the tragic deaths in 1994!

    I fear that the proposed removal of tyre warmers would be more of a safety issue than getting rid of TC.

    The one thing it might do is weed out those drivers who actually shouldn’t be driving an F1 car.

  3. Michael K said on 22nd November 2007, 16:06

    Removing TC just puts more pressure on the driver and we will see who can make the cut

  4. AmericanTifosi said on 22nd November 2007, 18:39

    I can’t wait for ’08! I think the TC ban will really show who the most skilled drivers on the grid are, the racing will be better and hopefully some more drivers who can master the cars who may not be at the best team will be on a more even platform with Ferrari and McLaren.

    Happy Thanksgiving from your colonial cousins across the pond!

  5. oliver said on 22nd November 2007, 19:28

    Its the drivers that dont get too emotional that stand to benifit in the no traction control era. If we have the same kind of rainfall that was experienced this 2007 season at Fuji, next year, it could spell disaster for the race itself.

    If they do go ahead and also ban tire warmers, coupled with no traction control, we may yet have ice skating on the race track, at least during starts and pitstops.

  6. I agree with Oliver that they should keep tyre warmers as a safety feature – but slicks can give a good driver the edge – and maybe give closer and fairer racing.
    Dispose of the compulsory tyre change as during the course of many of the races – they will have to change anyway – we see it all the time apart from mclaren when stevie wonder would have noticed that Lewis needed to change – at least give it a try Fia

  7. Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine) said on 22nd November 2007, 20:21

    I don’t agree about keeping tyre warmers for safety – drivers know they have to heat up new tyres and in other series (like Champ Car) where they don’t have them it’s expected to be part of their skill.

    Tyre warmers were first brought into F1 (in the mid ’80s I think) for performance – not safety – and I think getting rid of them would make the drivers work harder and not necessarily compromise safety.

  8. Eric M. said on 22nd November 2007, 21:43

    Keith, I’m not too sure, but I think you attributed Massa’s comments to De la Rosa.

    I don’t really understand the safety argument against banning TC, as it seems the most difficulty will be exiting out of 1st and 2nd gear corners, where speeds are low anyways. Plus I feel that today’s safety standards are sufficiently high that F1 can afford to take a “step backwards” by giving the driver more control of the car.

  9. Keith Collantine (@keithcollantine) said on 22nd November 2007, 21:45

    You’re right Eric there was a sentence of Massa’s quote in de la Rosa’s. Thanks for the spot, have fixed it now.

  10. No T.C. will be great. I think what will happen is that at first (during the race) it won’t be no big deal. Then, people will find out they’ve burned out their rear tires and have to pit way sooner then they would want. What do you guys think?

    Yes, wet races could be very difficult. I guess that’s why we all don’t get to drive in F1!

  11. Tommy B said on 22nd November 2007, 23:29

    “Without traction control it is much more difficult to accelerate – you have to apply your foot on the throttle much more carefully” Hopefully this will give people better runs out of the corners allowing them to overtake down the straight. It was hard to overtake when all the cars were coming out of the corners identically

  12. Nathan Jones said on 23rd November 2007, 7:38

    the bottom sentance from nick heidlefd says it all, f1 fans rejoice at reading it!
    time to sought the men from the boys!

  13. Nathan Jones said on 23rd November 2007, 7:38

    Nick Heidfeld that is :)

  14. “The fact is I didn’t have any experience without traction control and I was rubbish.”
    – How did this guy make it into F1?!?

    But from a safety point of view, these limitations in the use of electronics look like a step backwards to me
    – Of course this is a safety issue, he goes off- roading all the time WITH TC.

  15. Anthony said on 26th March 2008, 12:19

    It looks to me like Massa isn’t good enough at throttle modulation! Bring back slicks and turbos! Haha

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.