F1 fans slam rigged German Grand Prix

The German Grand Prix was rated the worst race in three years by F1 fans.

F1 Fanatic has conducted post-race polls on what fans thought of Grands Prix since 2008. The German Grand Prix, which Fernando Alonso won after team mate Felipe Massa was ordered to let him pass, received a lowest-ever rating of 3.74 out of ten.

Over 3,500 fans responded to the poll after Sunday’s race and one-third gave the race the lowest possible rating.

There are the ten least popular races according to F1 fans since the start of 2008:

Ten worst races, 2008-2010

Ten worst races, 2008-2010 (click to enlarge)

Here’s a sample of the comments left by fans about the German Grand Prix:

Massa was robbed by his own team. Makes a mockery of calling this a race. He deserved the win and it would have been fantastic a year after his accident for all F1 fans, no matter which team they support, to celebrate his come back.

This is exactly why the rules changed and Ferrari should be disqualified for openly giving team orders. They would have had a one-two without team orders and the best driver would have won ?ǣ fair and square.

Typically, a race this dull would get a 5 from me. But Ferrari Team orders absolutely kills any credibility of this ??race??.


Now [we] will see for sure how neutral Jean Todt is as FIA President.

I rated one ?ǣ I think there was little in the way of battles. Temperature probably played a hand in this with it being cooler allowing the option to last longer.

Then of course we were robbed as fans of any chance of a race with the team orders.
Mark Skeet

I voted one, but only because zero wasn?t an option. That wasn?t a race. There was no race to rate. As an F1 fan, I feel cheated. Ferrari owe me the last two hours of my life back.

2010 German Grand Prix

Browse all 2010 German Grand Prix articles

Advert | Go Ad-free


72 comments on F1 fans slam rigged German Grand Prix

  1. adam mason said on 29th July 2010, 11:56

    you know the funny thing is,just a few races earlier Fernado ran Massa of the track in the pitlane in China,and from I what I recall everyone everywhere condoned this action- Fernada had been stuck behind the championship leading but slower Massa for so long-so many races-Fenando had no choice but to drive Massa of the cicuit, well this was bound to happen.

    • GeeMac said on 29th July 2010, 13:19

      That was different, we praised the opportunistic nature of the move (I certainly did), and it was a pass on track for position, not an ochestrated move. No one would have rated Germany 2010 as a 1 if Nando had passed Massa in a legitimate, on track move.

      • adam mason said on 29th July 2010, 14:06

        I just dont see running your team mate of the track in the pitlane, who’s the wdc points leader on a circuit thats as big and wide and provides ample opportunity for clean overtaking for a skilled driver as China does as opportunistic.Just my thoughts anyway.

    • John H said on 29th July 2010, 13:25

      That was legal. Big difference.

  2. Steezy said on 29th July 2010, 11:56

    How long can the effing Spanish grand prix last? This is ridiculous, the races there are always terrible. Something needs to be done.

  3. Dr. Mouse said on 29th July 2010, 12:01

    I don’t remember how I voted, maybe 3 or 4.

    I didn’t think it deserved a 1. Luckily I voted on monday, so my anger had faded a bit. The majority of the race was pretty dull, with only the possibility of a race between the Ferraris or Button/Webber to look forward to. This would have made for a 5-6 before the ‘incident’.

    After that, I turned the TV off. There was no point watching the end of the “race” as it was no longer a race. It was a processional finish, and completely ruined from that point on.

  4. wasiF1 (@wasif1) said on 29th July 2010, 13:47

    I am not surprise, in 10 years of F1 watching I think this is one of the race I didn’t wanted to see the highlights.

  5. SoLiDG (@solidg) said on 29th July 2010, 13:51

    I just rated the race without the Ferrari fiasco. But I can understand people giving it a low rating, as they feel cheated. It could have been such a fun battle, as it was for a few corners midway the race. Oh well.

    • adam mason said on 29th July 2010, 14:34

      yeah i think i gave 5 or 6 ,wasent the best race but a bit of racing BUT in hindsight i would rate it prob 10/10 for historic moments,up there with the history making first ever 6 car grand prix in 05

  6. explosiva said on 29th July 2010, 22:46

    Alonso may be a quick and gifted driver, but I’m really beginning to question him as a Man. Yes, that is Man with a capital ‘M’. After the events of Singapore 2008 came to light, he still said he deserved that win. He didn’t; anyone with a modicum of integrity would say that while the results show he was the winner, it was an undeserved win. Could you imagine how his reputation would’ve changed if he returned his winner’s trophy?

    Same with the German GP. It was an undeserved win. A driver with integrity would be able to admit that rather than going on robotically about how “every win is special”. I can’t believe he has the gall to say “this is ridiculous” on the team radio when he couldn’t pass Massa! How dare you feel that you’re entitled to win the race when you can’t even overtake your (supposedly inferior) teammate win the same equipment? A world champion? Alonso’s no world champion in my book.

    Massa has class and integrity in spades. See Brazil 2008. Alonso’s just a brat.

    • dsob said on 31st July 2010, 9:52

      Yes, yes, and yes.

      Well said.

      • Yes, yes and very much in agreement.

        At the moment ‘team orders’ improve a teams championship prospects without much detriment – bar the loss of a few bucks that only amount to mere fraction of the budget and the impeded driver only forfeiting a few points.

        How about; when a team deliberately moves one driver ahead of another (actually on the track) to gain championship points, the decision should be made with the knowledge that the 2nd driver will be penalised by twice (or more?) the points gained?

        A 2nd driver having mechanical problems / wear & tear in play are no excuse or they must drive through the pits.

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.