Who will win the battle of the team mates in 2013?

2013 F1 season preview

The Formula One field has had a shake-up during the off-season.

Eight drivers – one-third of those who entered the Melbourne season-opener 12 months ago – have gone. Five rookies have arrived to join five world champions and a dozen other drivers.

Red Bull and Ferrari have enjoyed several years of stability on the driver front. Elsewhere changes in the driver line-up will provide much interest in the coming months, such as Sergio Perez arriving at McLaren, and of course Lewis Hamilton joining Mercedes.

But whoever we’re talking about, the first objective of any F1 driver is to beat their team mate. It’s the closest benchmark, the only other driver who’s got the same chassis and engine.

Who will prevail in each of the teams this year? Compare the line-ups below and vote for who you think will come out on top.

Sebastian Vettel, Red Bull, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Red Bull: Sebastian Vettel vs Mark Webber

Sebastian Vettel Mark Webber
2012 281 points 179 points
2011 392 258
2010 256 242
2009 84 69.5

F1’s longest-running driver partnership at the moment begins its fifth season this year.

Although Vettel has never failed to end a season in front of Webber, it has been close at times. After 11 rounds last year Webber was still ahead of his team mate in the standings. But he lost a glut of points in the second half of the year due to a combination of unreliability, misfortune and driver error.

Which Red Bull driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Sebastian Vettel (89%)
  • Mark Webber (11%)

Total Voters: 515

Loading ... Loading ...

Fernando Alonso, Ferrari, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Ferrari: Fernando Alonso vs Felipe Massa

Fernando Alonso Felipe Massa
2012 278 122
2011 257 118
2010 252 144

Alonso’s margin of superiority over Massa in their three years as team mates so far has been emphatic and has widened year-on-year.

Despite rallying at the end of 2013 Massa ended the year with the worst points haul relative to his team mate of any driver on the grid.

Which Ferrari driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Fernando Alonso (94%)
  • Felipe Massa (6%)

Total Voters: 516

Loading ... Loading ...

Sergio Perez, McLaren, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

McLaren: Jenson Button vs Sergio Perez

After three years McLaren’s ‘dream team’ of British world champion drivers has been broken up.

Lewis Hamilton finished ahead of Jenson Button in two of their seasons together and scored more wins (ten to eight), though Button accumulated more points (672 to 657).

Sergio Perez faces a considerably tougher team mate than Kamui Kobayashi, against whom his progress has been measured so far. And on top of that he has the added pressure of joining a top team.

Which McLaren driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Jenson Button (80%)
  • Sergio Perez (20%)

Total Voters: 514

Loading ... Loading ...

Kimi Raikkonen, Lotus, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Lotus: Kimi Raikkonen vs Romain Grosjean

Kimi Raikkonen Romain Grosjean
2012 207 96

Romain Grosjean kept pace with his more experienced team mate in the opening races of 2012. But the gap between them widened considerably after Grosjean became mired in a string of incidents.

If he can stay out of trouble this year the gap should be a lot closer.

However he has his work cut out to get close to the level of consistency Raikkonen achieved last year. The 2007 world champion just kept racking up the points, leaving Grosjean over 100 adrift.

Which Lotus driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Kimi Raikkonen (91%)
  • Romain Grosjean (9%)

Total Voters: 515

Loading ... Loading ...

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Mercedes: Nico Rosberg vs Lewis Hamilton

The karting team mates of 2000 and 2001 have been reunited as Hamilton takes Michael Schumacher’s place at Mercedes for the 2013 season.

Hamilton had the upper hand over Rosberg in karts and he will surely be keen to assert his authority in his new team as soon as the season begins.

This will be toughest benchmark against which Rosberg has been measured in F1 so far. Inevitably a lot of attention will be focused on this line-up.

Which Mercedes driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Nico Rosberg (21%)
  • Lewis Hamilton (79%)

Total Voters: 518

Loading ... Loading ...

Nico Hulkenberg, Sauber, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Sauber: Nico Hulkenberg vs Esteban Gutierrez

Sauber are one of three teams to have selected an all-new driver pairing this year.

Nico Hulkenberg’s experience should give him an edge over Esteban Gutierrez, who was quick but error-prone in GP2 last year.

However Sauber has proved an environment where young drivers have thrived in the past.

Which Sauber driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Nico Hulkenberg (95%)
  • Esteban Gutierrez (5%)

Total Voters: 508

Loading ... Loading ...

Adrian Sutil, Force India, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Force India: Paul di Resta vs Adrian Sutil

Paul di Resta Adrian Sutil
2011 27 42

Although Di Resta and Sutil may not be the most exciting driver line-up F1 has ever seen, the battle for supremacy between them looks like it will be close.

Sutil had the beating of Di Resta the first time around in 2011. But he’s been on the sidelines since then while Di Resta has been accumulating experience, which should make for a hard-fought second round.

Which Force India driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Paul di Resta (49%)
  • Adrian Sutil (51%)

Total Voters: 511

Loading ... Loading ...

Valtteri Bottas, Williams, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Williams: Pastor Maldonado vs Valtteri Bottas

Pastor Maldonado heads into his third year as an F1 driver with his third different team mate.

Rookie Valtteri Bottas has been with the team for several years and is highly regarded by them. But race-rustiness has to be a concern as he was out of action last year except for tests and practice session appearances.

Maldonado is clearly quick and capable of winning races. But if he makes as many mistakes as he did last year that could leave the door open for Bottas to put him under pressure.

Which Williams driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Pastor Maldonado (50%)
  • Valtteri Bottas (50%)

Total Voters: 508

Loading ... Loading ...

Jean-Eric Vergne, Toro Rosso, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Toro Rosso: Jean-Eric Vergne vs Daniel Ricciardo

Jean-Eric Vergne Daniel Ricciardo
2012 16 10

Nowhere is the competition between team mates more keenly fought than at Toro Rosso, where the occupants of the two seats are vying for promotion to Red Bull.

Vergne beat Ricciardo on points last year, though some ill-timed car trouble for Ricciardo in Italy and Korea helped tip the balance. With a better car at their disposal this year we should get a better idea of the balance of power – and if either of them deserves to drive an RB10.

Which Toro Rosso driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Jean-Eric Vergne (35%)
  • Daniel Ricciardo (65%)

Total Voters: 497

Loading ... Loading ...

Giedo van der Garde, Caterham, Jerez, 2013

Caterham: Charles Pic vs Giedo van der Garde

Caterham’s new driver pairing may not have raced for the team before but they have previously been team mates.

Charles Pic and Giedo van der Garde drove for the Addax team in GP2 in 2011. Pic showed the same qualifying flair that was much in evidence at Marussia last year, taking three pole positions.

He won twice and ended the year on 52 points, three ahead of his win-less team mate.

Now their paths have crossed again Pic’s year of experience in F1 should stand him in good stead.

Which Caterham driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Charles Pic (84%)
  • Giedo van der Garde (16%)

Total Voters: 491

Loading ... Loading ...

Jules Bianchi, Marussia, Circuit de Catalunya, 2013

Marussia: Jules Bianchi vs Max Chilton

Marussia’s all-new, all-rookie squad are also graduates of GP2. Max Chilton was fourth in the series last year after winning twice in the last eight races.

Jules Bianchi did not enjoy the success that was expected of him in the category, finishing third in 2010 and 2011, so he switched to Formula Renault 3.5 last year. He came very close to winning the championship, missing out after a controversial collision in the final race.

Bianchi has ample F1 testing experience thanks to Ferrari and Force India, and was expected to make his F1 debut with the latter. Without a more experienced driver in the team this pair are facing a steep learning curve.

Which Marussia driver will finish ahead in the championship?

  • Jules Bianchi (87%)
  • Max Chilton (13%)

Total Voters: 499

Loading ... Loading ...

An F1 Fanatic account is required in order to vote. If you do not have one, register an account here or read more about registering here.

2013 F1 season preview

Browse all 2013 F1 season articles

Images ?? Ferrari spa/Ercole Colombo, Lotus/LAT, Williams/LAT, McLaren/Hoch Zwei, Mercedes/Hoch Zwei, Daimler/Hoch Zwei, Red Bull/Getty, Force India, Sauber, Caterham/LAT, Marussia

Advert | Go Ad-free


109 comments on Who will win the battle of the team mates in 2013?

  1. its sad really that the Hamilton effect has eclipsed the Mercedes team, seems that just because he is at the team everybody has forgot about rosbergs talent. i just hope that the rivalry between the Mercedes team mates will mirror the senna/prost years, both team mates only happy if they beat the other

    • Brace (@brace) said on 13th March 2013, 21:32

      I’m sure everyone in Mercedes is quite pleased if it doesn’t mirror Senna/Prost rivalry. You just have to take a look at Alonso/Hamilton to realize that there’s no way they’d want that. Although they might be wishing it somewhat subconsciously, while actually hoping that their paring is as strong as Senna/Prost or Alonso/Hamilton.

      I think they’d be perfectly happy if they had one driver who is able to extract maximum out of the car at every weekend.

    • clappy (@danielc) said on 14th March 2013, 3:25

      Were well aware of Rosbergs talent , he beat a old 40 plus legend no where near his prime.WOW

  2. Dion (@infinitygc) said on 13th March 2013, 18:32

    Vettel; Alonso; Button; Grosjean; Rosberg; Hulkenberg; Sutil; Maldonado; Ricciardo; van der Garde; Bianchi (People might call me crazy for Grosjean, Rosberg and van der Garde).

  3. BJ (@beejis60) said on 13th March 2013, 18:46

    I’m surprised of the PER votes… I feel him and KOB were both relatively equal last year except PER seems to have better luck with his tires in last years’ car and therefore got two more podiums. I truly don’t feel that PER belongs at McLaren nor does KOB belong to not drive in F1.

    Meaning that BUT should handle him quite easily provided car reliability.

    • avidal (@avidal) said on 13th March 2013, 22:35

      Just for the sake of argument, How do you get lucky with tire management. Kamui got the short end of the stick with Sauber pit stop strategies in 2012 and I believe he deserves to be in F1; however, Perez managed those first long stints pretty well, not locking or sliding to much without loosing time, then would get the softs to be very fast towards the end of the races. strategy not luck, talent? possibly.
      Do you think that Hulk should have gotten Mclarens ride? everybody here seems to think so dunno why though. In Brazil he was brilliant but thats about it.

  4. Tifoso1989 (@tifoso1989) said on 13th March 2013, 20:11

    Who voted Gutirrez ?????

    • avidal (@avidal) said on 13th March 2013, 22:38

      Me! If we get two or three races under the rain with these crazy weather ( global warming?) we are having across the globe, He will shine. In BMW USA , GP3 and GP2, everytime there was rain, he would pass drivers left and right. And then that Bahrain pass last year was magnificent.

  5. AdrianMorse (@adrianmorse) said on 13th March 2013, 21:15

    Vettel: I’d like to see Mark beat him, but Webber has problems stringing together a consistently strong season. 2010 was the best season of his career in that respect, and even with Vettel dropping a boatload of points due to reliability, it wasn’t enough.
    Alonso: Massa should have the raw pace to put up a challenge to Alonso, but I doubt he will have either the self belief or the support from the team to do it.
    Button: so far the result of the poll is quite one-sided in favour of Button, but I think this will be close in points. Last year may have taken some shine off his image, but when he’s not struggling with tyres and set-up, he’s a very strong operator.
    Grosjean: this is my first ‘hope’ vote. Currently 91% of the votes are on Kimi, but I think Romain can also do a strong season, especially if he keeps his nose clean the first couple of races. With Kimi, I’m never convinced he wants to win as badly as the other 21 blokes out there.
    Hamilton: although I hope and expect Hamilton to come out on top in this team mate battle, I think this could be close. So far, Rosberg has shown plenty of promise in his career, and there is nothing to suggest he couldn’t be a world champion one day.
    Hulkenberg: it’s quite possible Nico has been hyped up too much after his strong end to 2012, but he should still be able to get the better of his rookie team mate, who has struggled for consistency in his GP2 career.
    Sutil: there’s probably little to choose between Adrian and Paul, but I have a feeling Sutil will have a slight edge in the races.
    Ricciardo: JEV thinks he will qualify better on the 2013 tyres, but I still hope Daniel will get the better of him.
    Van der Garde: Pic came out on top when they were team mates in 2011, but it was by no means a one-sided affair. For much of that season, Van der Garde was the nearest challenger to Grosjean, though in the final two weekends everything went horribly wrong for Guido (partly his own fault).
    Bianchi: there’s quite a lot of hype surrounding Jules at the moment, though when I looked up his GP2 record recently I saw it was good but not great (some podiums and 1 win). Still, I also think he’s faster than Chilton.

    • Jono (@me262) said on 13th March 2013, 23:02

      Im curious to know why you believe Mark has all the support he needs at Red bull…its Vettel (& Uncle Marko) vs Webber so I consider that a worthy disadvantage :)

      • David-A (@david-a) said on 14th March 2013, 4:02

        @me262 – That’s not even relevant. Webber has lost to Vettel in every year that Vettel has driven a full season in F1. Webber is still a good driver though.

      • AdrianMorse (@adrianmorse) said on 14th March 2013, 9:10

        @me262, I believe Webber gets the same material and treatment that Vettel does. If not, I think Webber would be the first to let us know. Marko is a troll and I don’t think Webber is losing any sleep over his comments. Unfortunately, Mark has proved his own worst enemy on too many occasions. He fluffs too many of his starts, and often gets stuck in traffic when Vettel does not (Spa 2012 springs to mind).

        Btw, I forgot Bottas: Maldonado may intend to keep his nose clean, but I think from time to time the red mist will still descend and on those days the cool Finn will collect the points. Or so I predict.

  6. Brace (@brace) said on 13th March 2013, 21:37

    Toro Rosso pair is the only one where I didn’t vote because, when it came to it, I realized I have no clue what to think of either of them. Even to roughly pick one driver. Only time they attracted my attention was when they were being flamed/praised for letting Vettel through.
    I guess it say a lot about both the team and the drivers, when you have no opinion, even though I didn’t miss a race and I’ve been reading F1 news each day.

  7. So,

    The obvious ones: Vettel, Alonso, Raikkonen, Hulkenberg, Pic, Bianchi. No chance in hell for something to happen differently here.

    The obvious ones that I hope will prove to be not so obvious: Button (but I hope Perez will give him a hard time), Hamilton (but again, here’s hoping Rosberg will rise up to the challenge, just for the fun of it)

    The VERY interesting ones: Maldonado / Bottas (chose Maldonado, but it should be VERY close), Sutil / Di Resta (chose Sutil, and I truly believe he will edge Di Resta out by some points and by the best classification in a race as well), Ricciardo / Vergne (chose Ricciardo simply because he’s a better qualifier than Vergne and at least in theory that should give him a slight advantage)

    So, basically, for me there are at least three and at most five teams worth keeping an eye on, from the team-mate-battle perspective. And I took the liberty of rating them according to my personal interest: Williams, McLaren, Mercedes, Force India, Torro Rosso.

  8. Robert (@rob91) said on 13th March 2013, 21:56

    Red Bull: Vettel is defending 3x world champion and has beaten Webber in all 4 years together, no reason why that would change with the rules pretty much staying the same this year.
    Ferrari: Massa has never looked like beating Alonso on points in their 3 years together so far, I will be very surprised if this changes.
    McLaren: I reckon this will be a lot closer than most people think it will be and I tip Perez to just outscore Button in his first year at a top team.
    Lotus: I think Grosjean will be better this year but Raikkonen was very consistent last year so will probably be this year too.
    Mercedes: Like McLaren, this will be closer than expected but in the end Hamilton will score just a little bit more than Rosberg.
    Sauber: Hulkenberg should have little trouble in getting the upper hand over his new rookie teammate Gutierrez.
    Force India: Sutil has had a year of no racing whilst Di Resta has improved since they were last together in 2011, so it will probably be the Scot who prevails in the end.
    Williams: Bottas will do well in his first year in F1 but Maldonado is one of the quickest drivers on the grid and will be too strong for the Finn.
    Toro Rosso: I think Ricciardo will beat Vergne this year by a decent margin.
    Caterham: Pic has one year of racing in F1 under his belt and this will prove decisive against Van der Garde.
    Marussia: Bianchi will comfortably have the upper hand against Chilton.

  9. Lin1876 (@lin1876) said on 13th March 2013, 22:13

    A few interesting battles, but I think Force India, Williams and Torro Rosso will be the closest. Force India have two solid drivers, but I think Sutil’s experience will win out over a season, just. I think Maldonado is quick and will beat Bottas IF, and it’s a big if, he can drive consistently, otherwise I tip Bottas to win. Can’t call Torro Rosso, not convinced by either driver to be fair.

    • Lin1876 (@lin1876) said on 13th March 2013, 22:14

      By contrast, I expect Ferrari, McLaren and Sauber to be very one-sided. All three of those teams have a clear lead driver. The others have a driver who should win the battle, but it could swing either way.

  10. verstappen (@verstappen) said on 13th March 2013, 22:44

    Force India and Williams will be interesting…
    But maybe Rosberg or Perez’ will surprise us.

  11. d3v0 (@d3v0) said on 13th March 2013, 23:35

    Did anyone else get to the battle of the Toro Rossos and then even lower; the battle of the pay drivers – and just think “sheesh, who cares?”

    The only driver I am excited about this year is Bottas. To a lesser extent of course, Kimi. The only battle I am interested in truthfully is Nico v. Hamilton – because I rate Nico VERY highly, and Lew might be a bit distracted with all of his new freedoms (going out on a limb here).

  12. clappy (@danielc) said on 14th March 2013, 3:33

    Come on Rbull change driver so Vet is challenged more. Mark Webber is way two inconsistent , no doubt he will win a classic then go on his customary invisible streak , the guy drives a fast car for 3 years and he has won less than Ham and Button in last 3 seasons.

  13. mike-e (@mike-e) said on 14th March 2013, 3:52

    Rbr – vettel
    Ferrari – alonso
    Mclaren – perez
    Lotus – grojean
    Mercedes – hamilton
    Sauber – hulkenberg
    Fi – sutil
    Williams – bottas
    Tr- ricciardo
    Caterham – pic
    Marussia – bianchi

    Heres to hoping anyway.

  14. David-A (@david-a) said on 14th March 2013, 4:06

    Red Bull – Vettel
    Ferrari – Alonso
    Mclaren – Button
    Lotus – Raikkonen
    Mercedes – Hamilton
    Sauber – Hulkenberg
    Force India – Di Resta
    Williams – Bottas
    STR – Ricciardo
    Caterham – Pic
    Marussia – Chilton

    I think Chilton won’t do as badly as everyone says and may have the fortune of getting a lucky highest finish.

  15. SundarF1 (@sundarf1) said on 14th March 2013, 6:01

    Between the Marussia and Caterham drivers, everything can change in one mad race so there’s no point in predicting it. But I’m surprised at the confidence people have in Ricciardo and #BOTTAS (Great, now I’m subconsciously typing his name as a hashtag). I reckon Vergne is better on race day and if he can get his qualifying sorted he could comfortably beat Ricciardo. Also, Maldonado is seriously quick, and last year he showed an ability to learn from mistakes. #BOTTAS will have to adapt, endure the rookie mistakes, and he will have to be extraordinary to beat Pastor this season.

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments must abide by the comment policy. Comments may be moderated.
Want to post off-topic? Head to the forum.
See the FAQ for more information.